Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Neoliberalism is an affective event – in order to challenge it, our resistance must be affective too

Zembylas 19 [Michalinos Zembylas (2019): The affective dimension of everyday resistance: implications for critical pedagogy in engaging with neoliberalism’s educational impact, Critical Studies in Education, DOI: 10.1080/17508487.2019.1617180]//jz

Resistance is a central concept of the social sciences – a concept that has been widely used in feminist, cultural, poststructural, postcolonial and critical theories (Johansson & Vinthagen, 2016). Despite its extensive use, however, there is considerable disagreement and ambiguity as to what exactly it denotes (Hollander & Einwohner, 2004, p. 549). In their frequently cited review of the origin and status of the concept in the social sciences, Hollander and Einwohner point out that resistance has been used in diverse, imprecise and contradictory ways. One can make a similar argument about critical pedagogy, namely, that the use of the concept of resistance in this field has also been diverse and contradictory, depending on the theoretical framework within which resistance has been framed (e.g. see Kirylo, 2013). It is safe to argue, then, that there is no unified way of defining resistance in critical pedagogy besides a general understanding of this concept as individual or collective acts of opposition, yet what constitutes opposition is not always clear. While debates in the social sciences over the meaning and implications of the concept of resistance have proliferated in recent years, one aspect that has not been adequately explored is the notion of affect (Hynes, 2013). As Hynes has pointed out, CONTACT Michalinos Zembylas m.zembylas@ouc.ac.cy Open University of Cyprus, P. O. Box 12794, Latsia 2252, Cyprus CRITICAL STUDIES IN EDUCATION https://doi.org/10.1080/17508487.2019.1617180 © 2019 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group since Hollander and Einwohner published their review in 2004 there have been significant shifts in social theory, and most notably affect theory, that call for a reconceptualization of what counts as resistance. ‘Affect’ can generally be understood as relational and embodied intensities that circulate as ‘forces of encounter’; in this sense, affect encompasses and exceeds more individualized conceptions of emotion (Seigworth & Gregg, 2010). What has conventionally been termed ‘resistance’, then, may be reconceptualized in terms of a flux of affects that produces political effects which challenge understandings of power or control (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987). Hence, recognizing the affective dimension of resistance complements earlier understandings of power and resistance on the basis of a simplistic opposition of human agency and social structure. As Alldred and Fox (2017) suggest: ‘power and resistance are differing aspects of the affective flux between relations in particular assemblages; all events are consequently sites in which both “power” and “resistance” may be discerned’ (p. 1170). In other words, it is suggested that there is need to pay attention to resistance as an affective event, rather than merely as an individual or collective acts of opposition. In particular, resistance against neoliberal reforms in education – e.g. high stakes testing, accountability, standards, and audit regimes (Giroux, 2008; McLaren & Farahmandpur, 2005; Taubman, 2009) – involves significant affective repercussions for teachers and students (Zembylas, 2018b; Bialostok & Aronson, 2016; Hanley, 2015; Moffatt et al., 2018). While there are many definitions of neoliberalism, generally it denotes emphases on productivity, economic liberalization policies, and the significance of the individual (see Springer, Birch, & MacLeavy, 2016). Neoliberalism itself, then, is an affective event, as collective affects emerging from neoliberal policies and practices (e.g. fear, anxiety, anger) are inextricable aspects of the sites, networks and flows of neoliberalism in societies (Anderson, 2014, 2016). Scholars of critical pedagogy have analyzed the pedagogies of the neoliberal project, whose aim is to produce apolitical consumers and future citizens (Odysseos & Pal, 2018), yet the affective dimension of resistance against neoliberalism’s educational impact has not been adequately theorized. The main objective of this article, then, is to discuss the affective dimension of resistance in critical pedagogy in a way that would recognize neoliberalism’s affective repercussions. The point is not merely to show that affect is involved in the emergence of resistance in critical pedagogy, but rather to expand the articulation of resistance in neoliberal education through the lens of affect theory. Specifically, I am interested in theorizing how critical pedagogy can cultivate ‘everyday’ or ‘invisible’ acts of resistance (Scott, 1985, 1989, 1990) that constitute forms of ‘counter-conduct’ (Foucault, 2009) in ways that acknowledge, engage with, and further enhance teachers’ and students’ critical engagement with the affective aspects of resistance and neoliberalism.1 In other words, I theoretically bring together critical pedagogy, affect, everyday resistance, and counter-conduct to examine the following questions: How might we understand resistance in critical pedagogy as a form of affective work? What are the pedagogical implications of recognizing the affective dimension of resistance, particularly in relation to cultivating counter-conductive practices towards neoliberalism?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.