Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their understanding of resistance refuses an analysis through affect theory – this dooms their movement to failure as they fall victim to the psychic impacts of neoliberal violence

Zembylas 19 [Michalinos Zembylas (2019): The affective dimension of everyday resistance: implications for critical pedagogy in engaging with neoliberalism’s educational impact, Critical Studies in Education, DOI: 10.1080/17508487.2019.1617180]//jz

In this section, I briefly illustrate how resistance is an affective movement of becoming, rather than an individual act, with consequences for students’ and educators’ bodies, theory, research and practice in education. While others have acknowledged the role of emotions and affect in making sense of how neoliberal changes in education are experienced by students and educators (e.g. see Bialostok & Aronson, 2016; Hanley, 2015; Moffatt et al., 2018), my illustrations – which come from my own research over the years (e.g. Zembylas, 2010, 2015, 2018b, 2018c; Bozalek & Zembylas, 2018) – intend to demonstrate not only how neoliberal policies in education use affects (e.g. fear, anxiety) to produce certain subjectivities (e.g. see Finn, 2016; McKenzie, 2017; Sellar, 2015; Staunæs, 2011), but also how educators and students engage in micro-political movements of affective resistance. To do so, I am using the idea of policy prolepsis introduced by Webb and Gulson (2012) as a methodological tool to identify the particular ways neoliberal policies in education induce and prompt particular behaviors and desires in educators and students.2 Policy prolepses, according to Webb and Gulson, are a category of becoming-policy that shape policy interpretations and practices within the spaces of desired, yet incomplete, policy initiatives and interpretations. ‘Policy prolepses operate through affective tones’ (ibid., p. 91) and ‘are coded affectively’ (ibid., p. 92), positioning policy interpretations as well as subjects themselves. What follows, then, are two brief illustrations of policy prolepsis that show the complexities of affective resistance produced in neoliberal education and its implications. The first example is concerned with how the becoming-policy of standardized professional standards in schools operates affectively in paradoxical and unexpected ways; the second example is concerned with identifying the ambivalent affective assemblages of educators’ and students’ resistance against neoliberal policies at the university level. In the first example, it is shown how the politics of standardized professional standards in schools instill fear, anxiety, stress and anger in teachers, who generate 8 M. ZEMBYLAS micro-political ways of resisting the affective atmospheres invoking normalization of teachers’ pedagogies (see Zembylas, 2010, 2018b). For example, teachers engage in false compliance, agreeing at a rhetorical level with some aspects of professional standards, while resisting them in practice or denouncing standards in small circles of trusted colleagues. Importantly, teachers acknowledge the emotional ambivalence of engaging in false compliance: the assemblages of fear and anxiety on the one hand, and the affective atmospheres of solidarity with colleagues, on the other. Clearly, resistance is not always progressive or emancipatory, as teachers themselves often recognize that their subjectivities are caught up in the affective conditions created by such policy interventions, producing tensions, paradoxes and ambivalences in their lives. One may, in fact, explore the numerous (anticipated and unanticipated) micro-political ways of resistance by teachers that might change the rhythms of schooling, producing alternative affective spaces that sometimes enable new embodied encounters and relations (e.g. between teachers and students or between teachers and their colleagues), while other times simply reinforce the negative atmosphere of fear or anger. Illuminating the counter-conductive elements of teachers’ resistances can reveal more specifically how counter-conduct is always prone to the entanglement of governing and surveillance practices (Odysseos & Pal, 2018). Hence, teachers’ affective resistance towards standardizing processes in schools finds itself caught between a negative affective atmosphere (e.g. fear or anger) that could be reproduced and, at the same time, the production of new and unexpected ways of resistance against the material and affective forces that impinge on teachers’ bodies. In all of these different possibilities, an analysis of the affective dimension of resistance requires that we focus upon the micro-politics of the (intended and unintended) affective assemblages in which teachers are a part of. My second example pertains to university students’ protests in 2015 and 2016 against neoliberal and colonial education policies in South Africa, calling for decolonizing higher education and greater access to education, which has resulted in disruptions of examinations and academic programs (Zembylas, 2018c; Luescher & Klemenčič, 2016; Nyamnjoh, 2016; Pillay, 2016).3 I want to draw attention to students’ collective affects (e.g. anger) which circulated through affective economies that operated across universities in the Western Cape (Bozalek & Zembylas, 2018). Collective affects were invigorated by a growing protest against neoliberal and colonial policies in higher education. The anger instilled in students by such policies was transmitted onto local university communities by circulating images of protests through the media. In particular, protests have become a prominent feature of public and university life in South Africa. The process of students’ occupation of university premises, in some cases, and the visibility it gave, especially through violence and the damages caused to university property, made it a transfiguring moment in the lives of the participants and the local community. Hence, there were voices who acknowledged their concomitant responsibility as a result of performing damage to public property that cost considerable amounts of money at a time of scarcity of resources. In our research, for example, there were students and educators who noted how, and in which ways, their subjectivities were produced within assemblages that included ambivalent affective economies – on the one hand, an assemblage of anger against neoliberal policies; on the other hand, CRITICAL STUDIES IN EDUCATION 9 an assemblage of disappointment and skepticism for the use of violence as a form of protest, thus questioning the moral legitimacy of (violent) resistance. Counter-conduct offers a compelling concept to understand the form of students’ protests as refusals of subjectivities and as acts of disobedience against being conducted as ‘consumer-students’ (Odysseos & Pal, 2018). However, the framework of counter-conduct, also allows us to grasp counter-conducts as affective mechanisms that may either forge new ways of resisting neoliberal policies or could become co-opted by the politics of violence. Through this tension, it is shown that there are ambivalent affective atmospheres circulating in counter-conductive practices of students and educators that could neither be ‘simply oppositional nor always fully articulated as part of a clear and long-term strategy of resistance’ (Odysseos & Pal, 2018, p. 17). These observations illuminate the affective ambivalence and paradoxicality of resistance against neoliberal policies; in other words, there are limitations in resistance efforts that signal clearly that such attempts may end in failure, possibly reproducing the risks that neoliberalism preys upon. This brief illustration also shows that any such analysis needs to remain attuned to exploring neoliberal policies in education as complex affective sites of producing and contesting subjectivities of students and educators – sites that are open to evading, resisting and redirecting neoliberal and colonial imperatives (Odysseos & Pal, 2018).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.