Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The neg defines oppression through the binary of whiteness in opposition to blackness – this essentialized view of oppression leads to the prioritization of race over all other forms of oppression and perpetuates gendered violence

DWP 13 (Dearest White People, internet blog cultural poltics, "The Black Mythical Norm: Intersectionality and the Nationalist Construction of “Blackness”," April 16, dearestwhitepeople.wordpress.com/2012/04/16/black-mythical-norm/)

In “Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference,” Audre Lorde defines what she calls a “mythical norm” in the United States, which is usually “white, thin, male, young, heterosexual… and financially secure” (Lorde, 2009, p. 517). With regards to this default American, Black Nationalism strives to build racial solidarity around the black community’s common deviation from the norm: Black people are not white. However, this essentialized view of black people often leads to prioritization of race over all other “deviations” by those black individuals whose identities are most closely aligned with the norm. In this nationalist construction of blackness, the black, thin, male, young, heterosexual, financially secure person becomes the “default” black person. According to Mark Anthony Neal, this nationalist construction of “blackness” led to the creation of the “Strong Black Man” figure, which Neal posits “can be faulted for championing a stunted, conservative, one dimensional, and stridently heterosexual vision of black masculinity” (Neal, 2005, p. 24), often to the detriment of those persons within the black community whose experiences with racial oppression intersect with other oppressive forces based on gender, sexuality, class, age, or any other deviation from the nationalist-constructed notion of “blackness.” This paper will explore the ways in which the nationalist-propagated image of the “Strong Black Man” interfaces with intersectionality of racial, gender, and sexual oppression, and attempt to grapple with the question: “who is Black enough?” The notion of not being “black enough” reverberates throughout black feminist and masculinist writings. In “Where We Live,” Essex Helphill states, “I’m as black as anyone, but not by the criteria the nationalists construct” (Belton, 1995, p. 214). In the same piece, in reference to the Million Man March, Isaac Julian laments, “It’s about another spectacle of middle-class black straight men claiming ownership of blackness” (Belton, 1995, p. 214). Audre Lorde echoes this sentiment, proclaiming, “Black women who once insisted that lesbianism was a white woman’s problem now insist that black lesbians are a threat to black nationhood, are consorting with the enemy, are basically unblack” (Lorde, 2009, p. 521). In “Having Their Say,” Rudolph Byrd speaks to the connections between the oppression of women and homosexuals in the black community, stating, “I decided not to waste any more time with those folks because I understood that I could never be Black enough for them… And so it was my experience with homophobia and the rejection of my blackness that caused me to empathize with women” (Cole & Guy-Sheftall, 2003, p. 51). Alongside attacks on queer individuals for not living up to nationalist constructions of “blackness” come accusations of betrayal and treachery toward black feminists and womanists who dare speak out against black male sexism. As Lorde asserts, “Black women’s literature is full of the pain of frequent assault, not only by a racist patriarchy, but also by black men. Yet the necessity for and history of shared battle have made us, black women, particularly vulnerable to the false accusation that anti-sexist is anti-black” (Lorde, 2009, p. 520). Despite feeling marginalized from within their own black communities, women and men who don’t fit into essentialized notions of “blackness” often don’t wish to separate themselves from those black males who propagate sexist, heterosexist, and misogynistic attitudes. Unlike self-identified white marginalized individuals who advocate fractionalization from their white heterosexual male oppressors, black people faced with intersecting systems of oppression are still able to feel united with black nationalists in their struggle against racial oppression. This may be because the white “community” in the United States is no community at all, but rather merely a built-in privilege that has been so long characterized as “default” that it allows white women, lesbians, gay men, and transgendered individuals to define their identities in terms of their own experience, without ever needing to contemplate race. In contrast to this, women, lesbians, gay men, and transgendered individuals in the black community must view their condition through the lens of their experiences with multiple layers of oppression, which means that a separationist attitude within their racial category is not so simple. As stated by the Combahee River Collective, “Our situation as black people necessitates that we have solidarity around the fact of race… We struggle together with black men against racism, while we also struggle with black men about sexism” (The Combahee River Collective, 2009, p. 504). The collective struggle against racism, although ripe with complexity, is not one that many Black people seek to abandon, regardless of potentially harmful nationalist sentiments. Because the intersectionality of oppressions facing black people who deviate from the essentialized, or default, image of “blackness” occur simultaneously, it is often difficult for individuals who must cope with many intersecting systems of oppression to separate their basis of oppression into categories and prioritize them in the same way that a black heterosexual male may be able to. The ability and willingness to prioritize identities has much to do with power relationships both among black people and relative to white people. As black nationalists rally together to combat forces of racism, they often strategically seek to do so in ways that run parallel to the white patriarchal power structure. As Isaac Julien argues, “It’s a question of power. Black men have been rendered powerless by the dominant society, and it’s that drive to have power at any cost, no matter what is silenced or dismissed” (Belton, 1995, p. 213). Upon deeper analysis of this quote, it becomes apparent that although much of the black community has been “rendered powerless,” the heterosexual black man in particular has been marginalized by the white supremacy system alone. Because the system of patriarchy allows heterosexual black men to focus on only one of their identities as the object of oppression, these individuals are elevated to a place of power within the black community where they are able to feel anger toward those black people whom they see as raising “other” identity issues that complicate what Angela Davis aptly called “narrow nationalism” (Davis, 1992, p. 320). According to Audre Lourde, “Within black communities, where racism is a living reality, differences among us often seem dangerous and suspect. The need for unity is often misnamed as a need for homogeneity, and a black feminist vision mistaken for betrayal of our common interests as people” (Lorde, 2009, p. 519). One of the greatest pitfalls of Black Nationalism and essentialism is that as a strategy for white acceptance and assimilation into white American culture it is premised on the black community’s acceptance of other power constructs such as patriarchy and heteronormativity. Norm R. Allen, Jr. calls this strategy “Reactionary Black Nationalism.” Allen, Jr. posits, “‘On the one hand, Reactionary Black Nationalists advocate self-love, self-respect, self-acceptance, self-help, pride unity’—all valuable and needed attributes for members of black communities and institutions—but also promote ‘bigotry, intolerance, hatred, sexism [and] homophobia’ among other things” (Neal, 2005, p. 23). This hypothesis is furthered by evidence of acceptance in the nationalist community of what Louis Farrakhan called “defects of character.” Just as Farrakhan was forgiven for his self-described “heart… dark with hatred” (Farrakhan, 1996, p. 11), as apparently shown in his blatant sexism and heterosexism, and Eldridge Cleaver is still held in high regard despite his misogyny and homophobia, Reactionary Black Nationalists’ chauvinist sentiments are “largely ignored or seen as excusable in a world where ‘race’ often trumps ‘gender’ and ‘sexuality’ as meaningful issues within the black community” (Neal, 2005, pp. 23-24). By prioritizing race in the context of oppression, black heterosexual males silence voices within the black community that they see as obstacles to their strategy of gaining acceptance and power for “black people” as defined by their own construct.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.