Their desire for purity and authenticity limits the possibility for the creation of complex communication communities that limits the praxis for engagement and normalizes dehumanization of victims of heterosexism
Hoagland 7 (Sarah, Professor of Philosphy and Women Studies at Northeastern Illinois University in Chicago, Collective Member of the Institute of LEsbian Studies and of the Escuela Popular Norteña, "Heterosexualism and White Supremacy," Hypatia 22.1, 166-185, Muse)
We Are Everywhere . . . Or Not at All Communities, of course, can become oppressive in critical ways, particularly when their practitioners think of them as institutions rather than contexts (looser and more ambiguous), for example, when those assuming "leadership" act in terms of purity and authenticity (note Lugones 2003, chap. 7). What brings lesbians together in community? Not fear, which is the current basis of U.S. solidarity, nor is it common oppression. To begin with, there is our desire. Desire and creativity are a central part of our possibilities, ingenious lesbian creativity, making so much—bookstores, coffee houses, poetry, publishing houses, music, bars, sports teams, record companies, theory, music festivals, jewelry, methods of healing. And what are possibilities of lesbian communities? In addition to loving women, because we are everywhere, there is enacting a praxis of engaging through difference rather than similarity, at first brought as a structural challenge by Audre Lorde. And that, it seems to me, grounds our possibilities, our work—not working for state-constructed "rights" but developing complex communication (Lugones 2006). I despair at the multilevels of heterosexualism and white supremacy by which our actions and imaginations are framed. It undermines possibilities of lesbian community and all the work in community building we have to do. In taking up el pasar discontinuo de la cachapera/tortillera del barrio a la barra al moviemiento (the discontinuous passing of the cachapera/tortillera from the barrio to the bar to the movement),9 María Lugones notes "la tortillera exists en la comunidad only as a pervert. Perversion constitutes her and marks her as outside of countenanced relationality. . . . En la comunidad, under the reigns of nationalism, la cachapera is silent, her meaning is made by others" (Lugones 2003, 174). Within African-American communities, out lesbians can be seen not as black, but as a white perversion (Carruthers 1979). [End Page 180] Yet "instead of cultivating her company toward impure shatterings of colonized communions, la cachapera becomes the Latina/Lesbian," moving into the territoriality of the Lesbian Movement—white locales, movement that does not move into Latino communities. So "Latina/Lesbian is an oxymoron, an absence of relation. Latina/Lesbian lacks a hyphen" and so hybridization. "The movement of the tortillera into the Lesbian Movement is a fantastic flight because she comes out to a forced speaking in a bifid tongue; because the eyes that see her coming out, remake her in their own imagination" (Lugones 2003, 174–76). And so the Latina/Lesbian who was working to make a place for herself in the campus Feminist Majority, not to mention the campus GLBTA, finds herself alone once again. At the "Heterosexism and Empire" workshop, one Vietnamese lesbian questioned, given the history of gendering in her country, what it would mean for her to talk about being masculine or feminine. A Korean transperson talked about the effects of Christian missionaries in her immigrant community. And a Palestinian woman noted there was an assumption that if people are queer, they are not going to be Muslim. Communities are the places of our possibilities, the places from which we grow. Moreover, my capacity to be a lesbian involves a relationality proscribed by dominant fragmentation, by heterosexualism. It animates through praxis of engagement.10 If tortilleras, bulldaggers, marimachas, swing girls, desi dykes, among many others, can only act out in lesbian community and are forced into the closet among family and local community; if la tortillera is cut off from a critical community, from a central source that nourishes her, if she can only be lesbian outside a critical place of her possibilities, and once outside only as someone acting out, if her possibilities of utcatha are negated, then as María Lugones suggests, she is a phantasm. And if she is a phantasm, then so am I. What, finally, concerns me is community, lesbian communities. That's what heterosexualism and white supremacy destroy. Lesbian activism has shifted from community building where we developed resources and came together to create, to make something happen, shifted from coming together in collective work to develop communities that undermine oppression, shifted from all that to asking and depending on the state to frame what is significant in our lives. I don't doubt the sincerity of those who are fighting hard for rights; I despair the appropriation of lesbian imagination, the loss of Sinister Wisdom. [End Page 181]