Engaging NATO is valuable – studying its internal dynamics is NOT endorsement – BUT, avoids co-option AND oversimplification
Wright 19 (Katharine A. M. Wright, Matthew Hurley, Jesus Ignacio Gil Ruiz. Katharine A. M. Wright is a Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK. Matthew Hurley is a Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK. Jesus Ignacio Gil Ruiz was the former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor, 2019, NATO, Gender and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429952074) nihara
Feminist knowledge of NATO is integral to addressing these questions. The study of an institution does not have to correlate with an endorsement of their politics and practices (Holmes et al., 2019). It is possible to remain a ‘critical friend’. A concept we introduce in the introduction to this book. This builds on the work of Rech et al. (2015: 56) who contend
that the study of the military, of militarism, and of processes of militarisation, should not be undertaken solely for its own sake, but should also by guided by the possibility of engagement with the forces and institutions responsible, and should not be bashful about doing so.
This is because such institutions, including NATO, are ultimately accountable to the civilian world and understanding how they function is necessary to critique them (rather than dismiss them) (Enloe, 1993; Rech et al., 2015: 56). Being a ‘critical friend’ means adopting a critical approach which calls these institutions into question and accounts for the possibility of change, supporting a normatively guided approach (Cox, 1981: 129–30). It entails engaging in complex and nuanced arguments and situating these in broader political considerations and in more nuanced ways than simplistic ‘pro-military’ or ‘anti-military’ positions are able to accommodate (Rech et al., 2015: 56; Duncanson, 2013). It means a commitment to praxis, which necessities engagement. Military institutions are often secretive, complex and contradictory, this means critical agendas can be vulnerable to co-option (as we go on to discuss in Chapter 4). Being a ‘critical friend’ therefore necessitates engaging in a process of reflexivity throughout the research process.
For Cohn (2011: 585), feminist scholars at the epicentre of ‘military/political/economic power’ in Europe and the United States have a responsibility to build knowledge of them. Basu finds there is also space to build knowledge of institutions from multiple-sites to enrich our understanding of how they function (Holmes et al., 2019). Drawing on her research on the UN Security Council, she asks feminist scholars to consider ‘what does the Council look like from different parts of the world?’ (Holmes et al., 2019). The same question could be asked of NATO given its shift to become a globally engaged actor post-Cold War. Thomson (2018: 6) argues that the engagement of such institutions with the WPS agenda necessities building feminist knowledge of them. She is right, however, this should not be the only impetus for such a move. Building feminist knowledge of how institutions such as NATO function is imperative to support the transformation of the current global order in line with gender just goals.
Feminist knowledge building of international institutions becomes all the more necessary for critical feminist IR as a project if we conceive of IR and international relations as co-constitutive. In leaving the study of institutions such as NATO to ‘mainstream’ IR scholars, we neglect the possibilities for change and resistance in the international system. The existing global order, of which NATO is part, is gendered, racialised and classed. In order to transform it, we need to politicise ‘which and when differences matter; why inequalities persist; and where military women and men are not equally recognised, positioned or privileged’ (Henry, 2018: 2).