Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff can’t solve—personal connections means disinformation doesn’t sway

Joanna Szostek, 2017, PhD in Politics from the University of Oxford and lecturer in Political Communication at the University of Glasgow, November 20, 2017, “Nothing Is True? The Credibility of News and Conflicting Narratives during “Information War” in Ukraine”// SK

The Ukrainian case similarly disrupts the assumption that audiences support a foreign state’s strategic narrative because they are “vulnerable” to its influence activities. To describe an audience as vulnerable implies that it is excessively credulous, lacks critical thinking skills, or perhaps lacks access to good quality journalism. In the present study, the participants who sympathized with Russia’s strategic narrative were no more credulous nor deprived of good journalism than their West-leaning and non-aligned counterparts. One cannot, therefore, attribute their attitudes solely to interaction between misleading Russian media content and their naivety. In fact, the Russia-leaning participants did not particularly trust Russian sources, and their views were shaped through exposure not only to the Russian narrative, but also to the fiercely anti-Russian Ukrainian narrative, which infuriated them. Their infuriation at the Ukrainian narrative can be traced to their personal, social connections to Russia, which they valued and perceived as threatened by Ukrainian politicians who had given them nothing in return. The present study, thus, supports the idea that social and communication “linkage” to a foreign state (Levitsky and Way 2010) at the individual level can play a role in strategic narrative reception. Linkage generates practical and emotional reasons for some Ukrainians to value friendly relations with Russia (Szostek 2017b), setting them at loggerheads with their government, which presents ties to Russia as thoroughly undesirable.

The present study has exposed complexities in what credibility means when it is applied to narratives in the news. Within International Relations, credibility has previously been described as “an important source of soft power” (Nye 2004: 106), but it has usually been presented as the straightforward product of honesty and good reputation. Studying how the Odesa diarists responded to news has shown that credibility also depends on whether sources and narratives address the issues of most concern to the audience, with skepticism elicited by what gets ignored, as well as what gets said. It should not be surprising that people negotiate the meanings of news with reference to their values and experiences. Decades of work on “interpretive communities” have shown personal experience playing a central part in how people negotiate the meanings of other genres, including soap operas and literature (Schrøder 1994).

At present, Russia, the United States, and other western countries are all keen for Ukrainians to use their media and support their narrative of political events. Politicians and some journalists tend to fight the opponent’s narrative by vociferously criticizing the opponent’s misconduct. The resulting repetitive and one-sided attributions of blame risk alienating the unconverted among the general population, who may perceive elites as dodging responsibility and avoiding more important issues. A lot of effort is currently directed into exposing and debunking “fake news” in the Russian media. Yet, the credibility of the Russian narrative among the Russia-leaning section of Ukrainian society is not based solely on their confidence in particular facts, but also on their priorities, which cannot be debunked. The “persuasive power” of the Russian narrative among a minority of Ukrainians comes not from propagandistic news alone, but also from people’s memories of their grandparents, and this is what makes it difficult for competing messengers to overcome.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.