Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The United States' current response to disinformation solves democracy - we respond by declassifying intelligence which increases trust between allies

Chris Zappone 22, an inaugural member of the National Security College’s Futures Hub in 2017. His focus has been on hybrid warfare, propaganda, cyber competition. He is Digital Foreign Editor at The Age and Sydney Morning Herald, where he was among the first in the media to report on the Kremlin’s efforts to interfere in the 2016 US election. He has presented on related subjects at SXSW in the US and testified to Parliament on the political risk of social media manipulation, March 2022, "‘It’s a clear pattern’: Why declassifying secrets is good for democracy," The Sydney Morning Herald, https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/it-s-a-clear-pattern-why-declassifying-secrets-is-good-for-democracy-20220304-p5a1nw.html //AShah

The Biden administration’s decision on Thursday to tell the public that Vladimir Putin was likely to use chemical weapons in Ukraine shows the extent to which the US strategy to battle Russia’s disinformation has evolved.

Once upon a time, such intelligence would have only been shared with the top echelons of allied countries. But in the evolving East-West confrontation, declassifying secrets is proving good for democracy.

In the new warning, White House press secretary Jen Psaki said the US had noticed an uptick in false claims from Russia about “US biological weapons labs and chemical weapons development in Ukraine”, and those false claims could foreshadow Russia’s real use of the banned weapons against the country.

“Now that Russia has made these false claims, and China has seemingly endorsed this propaganda, we should all be on the lookout for Russia to possibly use chemical or biological weapons in Ukraine, or to create a false flag operation using them,” Psaki tweeted. “It’s a clear pattern.”

After years of being outwitted by Russia on the world stage of public opinion, the US has found a surprisingly effective new counter-tactic: strategically declassifying and sharing intelligence.

For example, the US declassified and shared information warning of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in the months leading up to it. The US and the UK revealed that Russia had already positioned operatives to stage a fake attack and to install a pro-Russian leadership in Kiev. The US also repeatedly warned of “false-flag” operations to be staged by Russia as a pretext for invasion.

In contrast to the Kremlin’s famed use of internet trolls and bots to sow doubts in other countries, the US’s new strategy of sharing factual information has – at least for now – helped built trust between the US, its allies and war-hit Ukraine.

For more than a decade, democracies have struggled to convince their own citizens that they were operating in good faith.

In some case, the cynicism has understandable roots: the cooked intelligence seized on by the US to justify the 2003 Iraq War or genuine cynicism for Western power in the wake of the global financial crisis.

Putin and his partisans in the media have seized on those events and helped shape them – highlighting, and even exacerbating, the disorders through the dissemination of fake news, conspiracy theories and official statements.

But in preempting Putin’s invasion, the US has drawn attention to Ukraine, ensuring journalists flooded the country in the weeks before the attack.

This has allowed the nation of 44 million, itself apt in strategic communication, to establish narrative control of the event through the journalists’ work or through genuine video footage by citizens.

The US also appears to have extended a similar strategy to China, with US officials revealing Beijing shared information with Moscow about meetings Chinese diplomats had with their US counterparts before the Ukrainian invasion began.

On Thursday, Psaki also called out Chinese officials for echoing Russia’s conspiracy theories.

The success of this “pre-bunking” tactic relies on sharing credible information to forewarn allies and the broader public of lies told by the Moscow regime.

Whether Australia will embrace this tactic remains to be seen.

“It’s uncharted territory,” said John Blaxland who is professor of International Security & Intelligence Studies at the Australian National University. “But now that the US has done it, the prospect becomes more feasible.”

Forewarning the public about bad information to come has “been discussed at the individual level for years,” said Joshua Tucker, professor of Politics and Co-Director, Centre for Social Media and Politics at New York University. “Now we’re seeing this play out at a macro scale.”

“This is what the US is doing,” Tucker said. “It’s worked particularly well.”

The US government, even before it faltered in its ability to shape global narratives, relied on spin if not outright deception, in its involvement in the Iraq War, or in Vietnam, El Salvador and Cambodia.

But it was perhaps the Kremlin’s embrace of deception to interfere in the US 2016 presidential election (and in others around the world) that explains why the sizable disinformation research community in the West was surprised by the new tactic of declassifying intel for strategic advantage.

Many in that community have struggled to explain why Ukraine’s narratives have succeeded where Russia’s have so far failed - at least, outside Russia.

“We’ve gotten so hyper-focused on disinformation,” Tucker said, that we’ve missed the potential truth has to shape perceptions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.