Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Develops critical thinking and checks ethnocentrism -- net benefit alone fails

Hulme 11 – Ph.D. Candidate (Michael, March 23, “Education for Global Citizenship in America”, http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncg/f/Hulme_uncg_0154D_10611.pdf)

The richness and diversity of sources reinforces the need for their critical evaluation. This is more than understanding that all „data‟ are more or less partial, in the senses of being both biased and incomplete: a compounding factor is the extent to which interpretation may be influenced, possibly unintentionally, by the mediating influence of one‟s own (possibly ethnocentric, certainly partial) view of the world. Even where ethnocentrism is not a factor, interactions with others might nevertheless be perceived as ethnocentric, especially in the minds of those whose understanding of the US and Americans have already been adversely prejudiced, in the same way as some Americans have internalized prejudices against others. This points to a greater need to develop the willingness to try to see the world through the eyes of others – and conversely to help others to see the world through American eyes (though without imparting any sense of superiority). Developing this skill, and generally developing awareness and understanding of others‟ perspectives, might additionally inform students‟ perceptions of bias in domestic media, domestic political representations, and other domestic sources. It should also provide insights into the extent to which media channels reinforce the prejudices of their respective audiences, no matter how ‘false’ those prejudices might be, effectively stifling critical thinking.

An example of a particular lesson here is to compare and deconstruct the various stories presented about a particular event or phenomenon in another country, whether contemporary or historical. These various presentations might include historical records, news media coverage, „official‟ statements, and stories shared by individuals with whom relationships have been established on the one hand, and the domestic equivalents on the other.87 Comparisons of this sort may well provide significant insights into how others (even those essentially friendly to the US) view the US and Americans, and why they do so. This in turn might lead to some understanding of others‟ behavior, which would otherwise remain opaque. Some of the findings set out in Chapter IV constitute cases in point, two example being on the one side you say we want to assist you, but on the other side you are pointing fingers at us. So which way do you want to be, a devil or an angel?

I think you have a lot of interest shown by the Western world to make an establishment, to establish their force in the military alliance but they aren't really responsible, ensuring responsibility in ensuring that it is used for the right purposes.88

The lessons implicit in this form of investigation should lead to a more critical evaluation of the myths of superiority and salvific mission which form the focus of this Dissertation, and facilitate President Kennedy‟s 1962 exhortation to “move on from the reassuring repetition of stale phrases to a new, difficult, but essential confrontation with reality” (Miller Center of Public Affairs, 2011b). This includes the extent to which America still clings to some isolationist, nationalist ideologies despite a proclaimed espousal of globalization, together with the symbols that are used to reinforce those ideologies rather than simply engendering a legitimate sense of community and unity – flags and Pledges being examples.89 They also include an ethnocentric orientation to other cultures predicated only in part on a reductionist view of those cultures‟ identity, potentiated by the demonizing rhetoric of those who “lead‟ the country, which characterizes others based on their different political or religious orientations (or some other facet of identity) as “evil”. There is also the hope that this will lead to an awareness of the dissonance bound up in beliefs about freedom and democracy on the one hand, and US foreign policy and militarism, including coerced regime change (both covert and overt) in other sovereign states, in pursuit of maintaining its (meaning Americans‟) „interests‟ abroad.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.