Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Narrow focus good—engaging small parts of the plan spurs adaptation and innovation that solves their offense, it’s net better cause it creates in depth debates instead of stale disad and case—you should reward specificity, not punish it --- this is the best internal link to education

Branson 2007 (Josh, NDT winner who became a policy analyst for major think-tanks, edebate, http://www.ndtceda.com/pipermail/edebate/2007-May/071122.html, 5/31)

B) How to make debate more like the technical policy world? Narrower debates. PICs are vital to this (sorry, Duck). Thinking back on my 8 years in debate, the topic about which I can best converse with experts about is the design of emissions trading schemes. That was because the literature was deep and the prevalence of upstream/downstream/auctioned/timetable PICs narrowed the debates and forced a real in-depth discussion. I just don’t think we get that in a ton of debates, because most PICs are either wanky rhetoric PICs (and yes I was an extreme culprit) or something even worse like Consultation. Thinking back on it, I don’t think that the legal topic was worded particularly poorly, I just think that our strategic norms of judging/debating create a lot of problems in generating the type of education a lot of us want. But one of the most striking thing for me about last year’s topic was that I learned more from Repko’s post about his day at the Supreme Court than I did from all the debates I judged combined. In any event, how to create the types of narrow debates that will general real sustainable expertise on topics is tough.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.