Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US conventional deterrence is unsustainable—waning public approval and Asia Pivot means European allies must be at the forefront of European deterrence

Geddings,Larry Jr V. 2018, Project Convergence Director at US Army Futures and Concepts Center at Us Army, May 2018, “European Deterrence for European Assurance: The United States and Russian Adventurism in the Crimea”, School of Advanced Military Studies US Army Command and General Staff College //skwon

Unsustainable Reassurance and Deterrence The United States’ conventional deterrence policy initially labeled the European Reassurance Initiative, and later re-titled the European Deterrence Initiative, was, and will remain, unsustainable in the face of a resurgent Russia in the early twenty-first century. The US deterrent strategy in Europe was in direct competition for US military presence and influence with other regions of the world. A perceived lack of return on investment, fiscal considerations, and a general weariness caused an erosion of American interest in a uniquely European problem. Without European allies and partners taking a front row seat in the security and stability of Eastern Europe, the threat of overt Russian adventurism will remain.

The United States’ tenure as a patron in Europe will continue, but, at a less intensive level than the expenditure and effort seen between 2014 and 2017. The fiscal expenditure of continual Army Armored Brigade Combat Team deployments, colossal military construction costs for forward positioning air forces and basing, and the political capital spent for national and international consensus will certainly curtail as the tangible outcomes of the reassurance and deterrence efforts become more common and less palatable by the voting American public. Fading images of “little green men” in Crimea from memory will lead to the questions of the necessity and effectiveness of US deterrence measures and the expected outcomes of those efforts.50 Additionally, the sustainability of a forward positioned rotation of almost exclusively US forces against a patient adversary is fiscally unlikely. A persistent Russia looking to regain hegemonic power far away from American shores will tax the American citizen in time, dollars, and perseverance making the possibility of a long-term commitment untenable. Finally, America cannot afford to wager on the European theater as the next significant defense and political challenge with a rising China in the Asia-Pacific region.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.