EU-NATO cooperation solves deterrence – broad coordination allows for extended deterrence
Nagashima ’21 [Jun; 05/18/21; Master’s in European Security from the Tsukuba University, Adjunct Professor, Graduate School of Security Studies, National Defense Academy, Lieutenant General (Retired); "European Strategic Autonomy and Nuclear Deterrence- Progress of EU-NATO Cooperation and Impact on the Indo-Pacific Region –," International Information Network Analysis | SPF, https://www.spf.org/iina/en/articles/nagashima_06.html //smarx, AZG]
In view of the circumstances surrounding the EU, the best solution for responding to the nuclear threat that Europe faces is not to use the European nuclear deterrence approach proposed by France, but to develop a cooperative nuclear posture through loosely-based cooperation, within a scope that does not violate the sovereignty of the nuclear countries(U.S., U.K. and France), as a part of the strengthening of the current EU-NATO relationship. This means a political process in which the items related to nuclear deterrence will be added to EU-NATO cooperation, and consultations and coordination on specific nuclear cooperation are started at a working-level. Albeit in the form of NATO's provision of extended nuclear deterrence to the EU, this is a realistic response that the EU, with its complicated nuclear issues, can tolerate in terms of strategic autonomy.
In other words, it is difficult for the European Union to achieve strategic autonomy in the core part of its nuclear deterrence strategy, and the solution is cooperation with NATO. Needless to say, NATO is an alliance centered on the United States, which contradicts the direction of Europe's strategic autonomy. However, I think that realistic decisions made by the EU, without being swept away by ideals, should be appreciated from a broader perspective.