Having debates over technology better prepares us to deal with it through technological literacy
Dakers 6 (John R. Dakers – Professor of the Philosophy of Technology at the Technology University of Delft, “Towards a Philosophy for Technology Education”, Springer Link, 2006, https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781403983053_11, MG)
Heidegger (1962) and Feenberg, in his critical theory (2003), suggest that a synthesis between these opposing polarities of rules versus interpretation is possible. Both argue that, in association with the instrumental role a technology may have, we must also give consideration to the essence of the technology in terms of its social and cultural implications. Out of this emerges a synthesis that leads to an anamorphosis in technology education. In other words, the technologies that we simply accept as presented are often distortions of the truth, much as the lettering used in road markings appears to be elongated and distorted from the point of view of a pedestrian. However, the same markings when viewed from a driver’s point of view, seen head on and from a different perspective, appear, as a result of foreshortening, to be perfectly in proportion. This is deliberate on the part of the designers, but significantly, very few of us, drivers or pedestrians, are actually aware of this. It is only by repositioning ourselves that we may begin to see a different perspective, and this may, in turn, serve to transform our previously distorted values by illuminating and clarifying the controlling logic of the technologically mediated world we inhabit (Dakers, 2005a). A technological literacy in which the dialectics of “calculation versus meditation, objectification versus art, ‘world’ versus ‘earth’, identity versus difference” (Kroker, 2004: 38) are explored is therefore a crucial part of a learner’s technological development.
Technology education in this synthesis should have a “relationship” with industry, but not a subservient one, not one that is simply in the service of industry. Critical debate about technology and the role that industry has in its development must be encouraged. These debates must engage with global issues relating the sustainable development of technology, methods and patterns of consumption, and their relationship to ecological sustainability. Technology is not neutral, and its proliferation in terms of mass production, if not challenged, threatens the democratic process.
Technology education in the twenty-first century can therefore no longer be programmed instruction with behavioral objectives that set out a “divide and conquer” approach to learning. The vocational and academic polarities in terms of technology education must “dissolve into reciprocity, each constituting the other” (Grumet, 1992: 31). Discourse regarding the very essence of technology, the way technology affects our cultural development and our participation in a global society, must become embedded into technology education. We must learn to interpret the world of technology for ourselves, and we can only do that through the engagement of discourse about technology. In order to do this, we urgently need to develop a new philosophy for technology education that has at its center the development of a technological literacy.