Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The affirmative’s free flowingness and multiplicity places indigeneity as a transient quality – “becoming” reduces the native to a colonial reverent, but never as a milieu from which becoming emerges.

Byrd 11 [Jodi A. Byrd (Chickasaw) is assistant professor of American Indian studies and English at the University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign.; “The Transit of Empire”; pp. 17-21; 2011; https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/the-transit-of-empire#:~:text=Jodi%20Byrd's%20book%20The%20Transit,the%20larger%20project%20of%20decolonization.]//eleanor

The Indian—as a threshold of past and future, regimes of signs, alea, becoming, and death—combats mechanisms of interpretation through an asignifying disruption that stops, alters, and redirects flow. This stopping of the world of signification is the same as Derrida’s “tattooed savage” at the beginning of deconstruction. The Indian sign is the field through which poststructuralism makes its intervention, and as a result, this paradigmatic and pathological Indianness cannot be circumvented as a colonialist trace. In fact, this colonialist trace is exactly why “the Indian” is so disruptive to flow and to experimentation. Every time flow or a line of flight approaches, touches, or encounters Indianness, it also confronts the colonialist project that has made that flow possible. The choice is to either confront that colonialism or to deflect it. And not being prepared to disrupt the logics of settler colonialism necessary for the terra nullius through which to wander, the entire system either freezes or reboots. It seems slightly ironic, then, that many who pick up Deleuze and Guattari’s work use language similar to “Experiment, don’t signify and interpret!” to describe the possibilities of reframing the world through affect and affective relationships that move toward the states of enchantment, ecstasy, and the everyday. Brian Massumi’s cultivation of deviation and contagion to foster radicalism at the crossroads between science, humanities, and cultural studies contains similar Castanedian staccato imperatives: “Let it. Then reconnect it to other concepts, drawn from other systems, until a whole new system of connection starts to form. Then, take another example. See what happens. Follow the new growth. You end up with many buds. Incipient systems.”⁶⁶ In a gesture towards “a thousand tiny races” in which he provides an alternative future for race to that of Paul Gilroy’s After Race, Arun Saldanha writes, “Race should not be eliminated, but proliferated, its many energies directed at multiplying racial differences so as to render them joyfully cacophonic.”⁶⁷ Jasbir Puar’s delineation of the biopolitics of the now in Terrorist Assemblages depends on A cacophony of informational flows, energetic intensities, bodies, and practices that undermine coherent identity and even queer anti-identity narratives . . . assemblages allow for complicities of privilege and the production of new normativities even as they cannot anticipate spaces and moments of resistance, resistance that is not primarily characterized by oppositional stances, but includes frictional forces, discomfiting encounters, and spurts of unsynchronized delinquency.⁶⁸ Each of these cultural studies moments flow from the phrase “Experiment, don’t signify and interpret!” that functions as a call for transformational new worlds of relation and relationship that move us toward a joyously cacophonic multiplicity and away from the lived colonial conditions of indigeneity within the postcolonizing settler society.⁶⁹ This Deleuzian and Guattarian motif, even if it acknowledges all the divergent discourses that come into race, gender, sexual, and class assemblages, smoothes once again into uncultivated wilderness that allows any trajectory or cultivation to enter it, but not arise from it. By extension, and even if one cannot access how these evocations of “the Indian” function within the plateaus opened by Deleuze and Guattari, “the Indian” serves as an errant return of the repressed that spreads along its own line of infection once the theory is taken up.⁷⁰ For example, Jasbir Puar, by restricting her analysis to the biopolitics of the post-9/11 coming out of U.S. empire as “an event in the Deleuzian sense, privileging lines of flight, an assemblage of spatial and temporal intensities, coming together, dispersing, reconverg- ing,” can discuss as sui generis the monster-terrorist-fag that emerges in the twenty-first century as a new phenomenon, despite the Wanted posters in New York the week after 9/11 that compared Osama bin Laden to Geronimo.⁷¹ Additionally, Puar discusses Jessica Lynch as a “heroic girlnext-door” in conversation with a “depraved, cigarette-toting, dark-haired, pregnant and unmarried, racialized” Lynndie England at Abu Ghraib. Puar does not even acknowledge Hopi Lori Piestewa, reportedly the first American Indian woman to die in combat while fighting for the United States. Piestewa died in the same attack in which Jessica Lynch was captured, and her absence is a telling amnesia within Puar’s discussion of how “nostalgically mourning the loss of the liberal feminist subject” converges “white liberal feminists and white gay men” and “unwittingly reorganizes the Abu Ghraib tragedy around their desires” through the now racialized body of the no longer white Lynndie England.⁷² Piestewa’s absence is yet another deferral that vanishes the violences done to indigenous women, and those same indigenous soldiers’ cathexis of U.S. nationalism and imperialism that signals an indigenationalism compatriot to the homonationalism that Puar defines as “the arrangements of U.S. sexual exceptionalisms [marked] explicitly in relation to the nation” that demobilize queer identities by normativizing certain bodies but not others within the enfranchisements of the state.⁷³ To phrase this slightly differently, the Indian is simultaneously, multiply, a colonial, imperial referent that continues to produce knowledge about the indigenous as “primitive” and “savage” otherness within poststructuralist and postcolonial theory and philosophy. As a philosophical sign, the Indian is the transit, the field through which presignifying polyvocality is re/introduced into the signifying regime, and signs begin to proliferate through a series of becomings—becoming-animal, becoming-woman, becoming-Indian, becoming-multiplicity—that serves all regimes of signs. And the Indian is a ghost in the system, an errant or virus that disrupts the virtual flows by stopping them, redirecting them, or revealing them to be what they are and will have been all along: colonialist. The Indian, then, is a Deleuzian event within poststructuralism: “To the extent that events are actualized in us,” Deleuze writes, “they wait for us and invite us in.”⁷⁴ For Derrida, as he grieved and mourned the loss of his friend and colleague, and saw in that loss the passing of a generation of thought, the event in Deleuze’s work becomes the Event, death, the paradox of humorous conformity of a leaping in place, an apotheosis of will. “‘It is in this sense that Amor fati is one with the struggle of free men,’” Derrida quotes from Deleuze.⁷⁵ Nietzsche’s love of fate, the invitation inherent in the will of the event opposes the ressentiment of resignation to become the point “at which war is waged against war, the wound would be the living trace of all wounds, and death turned on itself would be willed against all death.”⁷⁶ On the threshold, then, of “the necessity with the aleatory, chaos and the untimely” that is both the work of Derrida’s mourning of Deleuze and the haksuba of Southeastern cosmologies that Choctaw scholar LeAnne Howe defines in her work as headache, chaos, the collision of Upper and Lower Worlds initiated by colonialism, the Indian wills against the signifying system.⁷⁷ That the Indian represents the violent slamming of worlds in what might otherwise be fluidity and flow helps us frame the problem within a U.S. empire, with ties to Enlightenment liberalism, that continues to transit itself globally along lines put to flight by “the Indian without ancestry” that makes everyone its progeny. It is untimely as a site of the death of signification. That haksuba can additionally mean “to be stunned with noise, confused, deafened” signals the degree to which cacophony, whether joyous or colonialist, hinges upon the disruptions caused when “the Indian” collides with the racial, gendered, classed, and sexed normativities of an imperialism that has arisen out of an ongoing settler colonialism.⁷⁸ The Southeastern cosmologies of the Chickasaw and Choctaw imagine worlds with relational spirals and a center that does not so much hold as stretches, links, and ties everything within to worlds that look in all directions. It is an ontology that privileges balance, but understands that we are constant movement and exist simultaneously among Upper and Lower Worlds, this world and the next. In her poem “The Place the Musician Became a Bear,” Mvskoke poet and musician Joy Harjo sings about how Southeastern Indians have always known “where to go to become ourselves again in the human comedy. / It’s the how that baffles, the saxophone can complicate things.”⁷⁹ Harjo reminds us that there is always a prior “becoming-human” within Southeastern worlds that links us to the complications and improvisations of stars, spirals, and jazz. Much of the scholarship on U.S. imperialism and its possible postcoloniality sees it as enough to challenge the wilderness as anything but vacant; to list the annihilation of indigenous nations, cultures, and languages in a chain of –isms; and then still to relegate American Indians to the site of the already-doneness that begins to linger as unwelcome guest to the future. This last is particularly relevant to understanding how the United States propagates itself as empire transhemispherically and transoceanically, not just through whiteness, but through the continued settling and colonizing of indigenous peoples’ lands, histories, identities, and very lives that implicate all arrivants and settlers regardless of their own experiences of race, class, gender, colonial, and imperial oppressions. My point in tracing the Deleuzian wilderness and the Indian deferred is to detail the ways in which “the Indian” is put to flight within Western philosophical traditions in order to understand how the United States transits itself globally as an imperial project. As Derrida and Deleuze are evoked within affect theories, the “Indian” and “tattooed savages” remain as traces. Any assemblage that arises from such horizons becomes a colonialist one, and it is the work of indigenous critical theory both to rearticulate indigenous phenomenologies and to provide (alter)native interpretative strategies through which to apprehend the colonialist nostalgias that continue to shape affective liberal democracy’s investment in state sovereignty as a source of violence, remedy, memory, and grievability.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.