Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Role experimentation should orient our politics. the lens of a policymaker can alter our perception in ways that catalyze micro and macro political action. Investigating politics can expose faults in the system in order to foster broader forms of resistance

Connolly 13. William E. Connolly, Krieger-Eisenhower Professor of Political Science at Johns Hopkins University, The Fragility of Things: Self-Organizing Processes, Neoliberal Fantasies, and Democratic Activism, Duke University Press, 2013, 186

There is no zone of complete neutrality in a world of role performances. Obedient performances in cumulative effect tend to support the existing regime as they insinuate its dictates into our collective habits of perception, judgment, and action. Unless a dissident group of workers meticulously “works according to rule” to disrupt production through excruciating obedience in a way that discloses how tangled formal rules can become. Or a group creatively improvises on the performance of Bartleby the Scrivener, posing endless questions about the orders given to it until the machine overflows itself or is jammed. These indeed are creative role experimentations. So was the practice in Eastern Europe during the late stages of Soviet rule to clap endlessly when a Soviet stooge spoke, until the bewildered speaker was moved to sit down amid the roar around him. I recently attended a faculty meeting with the president of my university at which the entire faculty remained silent after his Ceo-style talk ended and he departed slowly up the aisle. Sometimes silence sends a message to power.

Our lives are messages.5 Role experimentation can disrupt and redirect the flow of authority, habit, institutional regularity, and future projection. It can also encourage others to look more closely at their own performances in this or that domain. Such experiments can also set the stage for more adventurous and larger scale actions. My examples will be limited to con- stituencies who are the most apt to read this book, though they could easily be adjusted to a broader array.

Suppose a constellation of students, studying to enter professional life, forms study groups to explore more closely how those professions presuppose and enforce a set of practices that contribute to the fragility of things as they simultaneously draw attention away from that contribution. The students may pose untimely questions in their political science, economics, engineering, medical, business, legal, and biology classes. If in a secular institution, they may seek out courses that complicate the assumptions of secularism. If in a religious school, they may organize a group to explore the history of atheism or of minority faiths that eschew the theme of a per- sonal God. They can engage experimental artistic work that stretches their habitual patterns of perception and judgment. The nature- and soundscape compositions of John Luther Adams have salutary effects on many in this respect. Such activities can also prime you to experiment with other role performances once you enter professional life. If a lawyer, you may organize to rethink your connections to the ugly prison system and to adjust your practice to protest its ugliness. Or you may give a portion of your time to challenge corporations, localities, and states that defile the environment. If a doctor, you may organize voluntary medical care for the poor and publicize what you are doing. In both cases these experimentations make a modest difference on their own, prime our capacities for more sensitive perception in other domains of life, and may prepare us to participate with others in yet more adventurous activities. These are minor moments, but an accumulation of minor moments can jostle settled habits of perception; they can encourage a readiness to become more exploratory; and they can extend the time horizon within which we think and act.

Suppose, now, you are middle- or upper-middle-class citizens in a polity that has competitive elections. You have become increasingly dissatisfied with the course your society is taking. Voting, while pertinent, seems radically insufficient to the issues involved. Its time horizon is too short and the strategic place of ill-informed undecided voters in electoral politics skews campaigns too sharply. Inequality has been extended. The lower reaches of society are left out in the cold and often blamed for the suffering they undergo. The news media are organized around scandal and a brief time horizon. Racial differences are exploited to break up potential coalitions on the left. A large slice of the population is periodically suscep- tible to war fever. Climate change is widely subjected to deferral, denial, or formal acceptance disconnected from action. And the right wing actively promotes filibusters and legislative stalemates to encourage more and more people to withdraw from citizenship and to tolerate the privatization of more and more of life.

The sciences and professions with which you are familiar are often too narrowly defined. Too many churches either provide refuges from the world or serve as sites of aggressive attack on ecological concerns, homosexu- ality, carriers of alternative faiths, or poor minorities. You know what po- litical party you support; you vote regularly; and you give time and money to your party. But you also find it difficult to connect the sentiments you profess to the role expectations sedimented into your practices of work, church, consumption, neighborhood association, investment portfolio, children’s school, artistic pursuits, and local news reporting. Now is the time to join others in becoming role experimentalists.

You may actively support the farm-to-table movement in the restaurants you visit; you may support the slow food movement; you may frequent stores that offer food based on sustainable processes; you may buy a hybrid or, if feasible, join an urban zip-car collective, explaining to friends, family, and neighbors what effect such choices could have on late modern ecology if a majority of the populace did one or the other; you may press your neighborhood association and workplace to buy solar panels and install them yourself; you may use writing and media skills developed in school to write for a blog; you may shift a large portion of your retirement account into investments that support sustainable energy; you may withdraw from aggressive investments that presuppose an unsustainable growth pattern, threaten economic collapse, and/or undermine the collec- tive future; you may bring new issues and visitors to your church, temple, or mosque to support rethinking about interdenominational issues and the contemporary fragility of things; you may found, join, or frequent a repair club, at which volunteers collect and repair old appliances, furni- ture, and vehicles to cut back on urban waste and increase the longevity of these items; you may probe and publicize the multimodal tactics by which twenty-four-hour news stations work on the visceral register of their viewers, as you explore ways to counter those techniques; you may travel to places where unconscious American assumptions about world entitlement are challenged on a regular basis; you may augment your pattern of films and artistic exhibits attended to stretch your habitual powers of perception and to challenge some affect-imbued prejudgments embedded in them; you may seek out new friends who are also moving in these directions. You may regularly relay pregnant essays you encounter to friends, colleagues, and relatives. A series of minor role experiments.

As we proceed our aspirational selves may now begin to exceed our operational selves, and the shame we feel about the discrepancy between these two aspects of the self may generate energy to enter into yet new modes of role experimentation.6 We thus begin to make ourselves and our engagements more experimental rather than simply falling into a ready- made set of role expectations. We have begun to become what Nietzsche calls “our own guinea pigs” rather than merely being the guinea pigs of those in charge of these institutions.

As such experiments accumulate, the ice in and around us begins to crack. First, the shaky perceptions, feelings, and beliefs with which we started these experimentations now become more refined and more entrenched. Second, we are now better situated to forge connections with yet larger constituencies engaging in similar experiments. Third, as these connections accumulate we may be more inspired to join macropolitical movements that speak to the issues. Fourth, as we now join protests, slowdowns, and confrontational meetings with corporate managers, church leaders, union officials, university officials, and neighborhood leaders, we may now become more alert to the institutional pressures that propel these constituencies forward too. They are also both enmeshed in a web of roles that en- able and constrain them and often more than mere role bearers. These roles too exhibit varying degrees of pressure and slack as they link the details of daily conduct to the strategic practices of the larger political economy.

One advantage of role experimentation by several constituencies at multiple sites is that it speaks to a time in which the drive to significant change must today be mobilized by a large, pluralist assemblage rather than by a single class or other core constituency. Such an assemblage must be primed and loaded by several constituencies at many sites. Role experimentations and the shape of a pluralist assemblage thus inflect one another.

We must condense some of the steps involved. But perhaps the multidimensional pluralist assemblage in which you have now begun to participate approaches a tipping point—crystallized, say, by movement back and forth between role experiments, shifts in the priorities of some strategic in- stitutions, and a change in the contours of electoral politics. Now a surprising event may occur, allowing these emergent energies to be crystallized. At this point some will enter the scene to say that no kind of “reformism,” no matter how extensive, is acceptable. We must wait for a bigger, more total transformation, they will say. Such an account will be offered at precisely this tipping point as the only sophisticated reading of the world. But it is not. Yes, roles, institutions, events, constitutive acts, and larger structures are interinvolved, with each enabling and limiting others. Yes, we do inhabit a world of multiple entanglements and interconnections. Yes, the primacy of capitalist markets and private ownership does give owners and high-rolling investors key advantages in setting the agenda of the state. Yes, states subject to public elections are also limited by systemic relations to corporate structures and the threat of capital strikes. Yes, extreme inequality, combined with legislative and court decisions inspired by neo- liberal ideology, do disenfranchise many as they release billions of dollars to right-wing electoral campaigns. Yes, private ownership of the media does give great advantages to the corporate establishment. Yes, dependent workers do face uphill battles in limiting capital through labor organiza- tion. Yes, the limited reach of semisovereign states in the global economy exerts corporate pressure on them, just as, inside the United States at least, the right-wing Supreme Court’s devolution of authority to states in a fed- eral system forces states to compete with each other for corporate favors. Yes, elected representatives are dependent on campaign money and their desires to find jobs as lobbyists after they leave office. Yes, there are pressures on many in the lower middle class to identify with the vision of the future publicized by those above them. It may therefore appear that there are no cracks and fissures in these interconnected processes. It may seem that you must either embrace the system with fervor, withdraw as much as possible from it, or wait for an explosion that changes everything rapidly.

The hegemony of neoliberal ideology reinforces such a reading of the alternatives, in its way, even as it otherwise emphasizes our inability to have a bird’s-eye view of the system. It offers a bird’s-eye view of the whole whenever it insists that market self-organization means impersonal market rationality. But repeated experience belies such an equation. There are numerous examples of surprising economic meltdowns, often ushered into being by submission to that very ideology. And periodically critical movements emerge, as if from nowhere, to challenge existing priorities at vulnerable sites. There is, for starters, the surprise of the Arab Spring, with its ambivalent possibilities; the emergence of a New Left in Euro-American countries in the 1960s and 1970s; the birth of feminist and gay rights movements in those same countries that have probed soft spots in churches, the media, corporate benefit packages, universities, state policy, and families; there is the “slut walk” by which young women challenged the idea that how they dress determines whether they deserve sexual assault; there is Tiananmen Square, which revealed currents of energy and protest in China that are still festering; there is the Occupy movement, springing as if from nowhere, to galvanize previously isolated pockets of dissatisfaction and unrest; there is the civil rights movement, which has reenergized itself several times; there are several ecological movements, mobilizing diffuse dissatisfactions with the direction neoliberal regimes have taken. Each of these events and movements exposes soft spots, cracks, uneven edges, and leakages in “the system,” through which new lines of creative activity can form and pass.

While under way, these become creative forays with differing degrees of self-organization built into them. If and as their success grows, they may expose yet more seams and cracks in a system that is far more replete with rough edges between its subsystems than either its most ardent ideologues or some of its structural critics may acknowledge. The cracks, edges, fissures, noise, and renegade flows in these processes, hidden by this or that streamlined view, are often rendered visible by such experimental actions. One creative thing about that slut walk is how it incited erotic energy and recruited that energy for critical politics. More such experiments of this sort are needed in other domains. There is no reason in the world to allow sensual desire to flow into the advertisement, sale, and purchase of cars, clothing, perfume, vacations, and jewelry but yet to purge it from areas in which it could help to instigate and mobilize productive political activism. Except a self-denying Puritanism within radicalism itself.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.