We should debate international relations as a normative sphere for developing prescriptive frameworks that are exportable – but, it’s only effective if debates are structured and positions are known in advance, which allows abstracting hypothetical scenarios from individual experience to develop universal principles
Lantis 4 [Jeffrey S. Lantis is Chair of the International Relations Program and Associate Professor of Political Science at The College of Wooster. He is author of Domestic Constraints and the Breakdown of International Agreements, and Foreign Policy in Comparative Perspective. Ethics and Foreign Policy: Structured Debates for the International Studies Classroom. International Studies Perspectives, Vol. 5, No. 2 (May 2004). https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/44218873.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A3276219e5a7f3bad3e332f8cbe491fd8]
Structured debates for international relations courses represent a synthesis of the active teaching methods described here. They draw on the role-playing dynamics of simulations, the narrative foundation of the case method, and a system for debate and critical analysis grounded in the argumentation literature.
Structured debates force students to define and defend policy positions that are assigned in advance. In this way, debates demand a level of personal engagement in the process, a measure of group collaboration on debate points, and a willingness to participate in a critical dialogue with the larger group about theoretically significant policy questions. Classroom debates are built on the foundation of a common narrative or background material similar to the case method. For example, students who are assigned to support the establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) have reviewed similar materials and issues as have those who must oppose it. Furthermore, they are encouraged to define the issue, interpret it through theory frameworks, and prescribe policy options to address specific, real-world problems.
These exercises are structured according to guidelines found in the argumentation literature. Students are sometimes assigned roles for debates in advance, and other times they are forced to defend a position assigned minutes earlier. Debates run according to the systematized format of some forensics programs, and discourse is structured in a way to achieve educational objectives. Students may be motivated by “winning” some of these debates, but they achieve important educational objectives in the process (Wood and Rowland-Morin, 1989). Argumentation in this form can serve as a medium for both engaged citizenship and critical thinking about potential solutions to contemporary challenges. But Cox rightly cautions that political argumentation should be seen as a “normative sphere” where there is less absolute truth than issues subject to interpretation (1981:127).
The literature on active teaching and learning stresses that exercises should be designed and implemented to fulfill a set of educational goals. While objectives may vary, these techniques are generally designed to help students move from theoretical discussions in the classroom to real-world experience. The incorporation of active teaching and learning exercises into international relations courses should also take into account the time requirement and intensity of the exercise, the amount of student preparation needed, and related resource concerns. Finally, most successful active teaching approaches include a period for reflection on theory applications and lessons learned from the experience. In Kolb’s experiential learning preference model, for example, particular attention is devoted to the importance of reflective observation about the exercise (Kolb, 1976, 1984; Fox and Ronkowski, 1997; Brock and Cameron, 1999). On a more practical level, debriefing can provide necessary closure and encourage students toward further discoveries.
The study of ethical dilemmas in foreign policy can achieve important educational objectives in courses on international relations. First, ethical dilemmas can be used to illustrate the complexities of contemporary global politics. Perennial themes like the struggle for state sovereignty, identity, and globalization may be viewed through the optic of ethical debates. Second, collaborative learning projects with defined objectives allow students to explore many avenues in relating theories to case studies in a highly systematic format. Debates with assigned roles also provide students with greater understanding of diverse perspectives on major issues. They learn more about the background and orientation of key players involved in political discourse, and this may promote a widening of their worldviews. Finally, students can increase their communications skills through interactions with their peers in the context of structured debates. These and other objectives are described in practical application below.