Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Even though issue specialization means that not every issue will be discussed directly every year, the skills and habits inculcated by our model are broadly transferable to issues of structural exclusion

Kevin J. Elliott 19, Assistant Professor of Political Science at Murray State University, 11/14/19, “Democracy's Pin Factory: Issue Specialization, the Division of Cognitive Labor, and Epistemic Performance,” American Journal of Political Science, https://doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12486

Perhaps the biggest problem with this hopeful vision of specialization's epistemic power is that not every issue will receive the attention of an issue public (Somin 2013, 106). This is because issue publics are an emergent phenomenon in the mass public and are thus constituted through self‐selection. This could bias their composition due to inequalities in civic skills and motivation (Verba, Schlozman, and Brady 1995). Self‐selection is exacerbated by the inclusion of associations and civil society groups within the issue public matrix, since such groups have a well‐known socioeconomic bias (Schattschneider 1960). Moreover, issue publics are endogenous to issue salience, or the public attention paid to an issue, since media coverage often plays a decisive role in directing public attention to certain issues. Media coverage can also be biased toward conflictual stories and insubstantial soft news (Shapiro 1998). This means not only that abstruse or technical issues may receive less attention in favor of the trivial yet telegenic, but also that those issues affecting marginalized groups might attract smaller issue publics than their objective importance11 demands. These biases create a serious problem for an epistemic account of issue specialization since it suggests there are pathologies of attention that can prevent issue publics from bringing their powers to bear on important issues.

These biases necessitate focused, institutional efforts to cultivate an interest in politics among disadvantaged citizens so they can help constitute new or less biased issue publics. For instance, Lisa García Bedolla and Melissa Michelson (2012) argue that campaigns’ efforts to bolster turnout among marginalized groups cause these groups to become durably politicized beyond a specific election, suggesting lasting prodemocratic changes in their cognitive and motivational orientation to politics. Such efforts should be systematically encouraged.

A more ambitious approach can be found in the online deliberative forums piloted by Neblo, Esterling, and Lazer (2018) involving elected representatives and randomly invited constituents. Three features of these forums make them well suited to addressing bias in issue publics. First, they reverse the usual direction of participatory bias, disproportionately engaging poorer and politically disconnected citizens (Neblo, Esterling, and Lazer 2018, 65). Second, by focusing on single issues, they concentrate citizen attention on issues that may not receive media coverage and offer disengaged citizens a manageable—because issue limited—entry point into politics. Lastly, unlike most blue‐sky reforms cooked up by political scientists, these forums incentivize their own adoption because representatives who participate enjoy a several‐point electoral advantage from satisfied constituents (Neblo, Esterling, and Lazer 2018, 109). Due to their electoral incentives, representatives want to participate and so need not be motivated by any special prodemocratic reform attitudes. Thus, there are ways to build complementary institutions to stem the biases inherent in issue publics.

Two considerations further lessen concerns about bias. First, issue specialization highlights the importance of the less organized part of issue publics—reversing the pluralist's error of emphasizing organized groups in the mistaken belief they are approximately representative—by emphasizing electoral incentives and information shortcuts, which operate in the mass public. Second, issue publics largely reflect inequalities in the political system rather than originate them. To the extent biases in issue salience and attention are corrected, biases in issue publics will also subside. This is important because it illustrates the neutrality of specialization; whatever issues attract public attention gain epistemically via this mechanism. In conditions of participatory inequality, this may lead to important pathologies. Yet examples like the civil rights movement and Black Lives Matter suggest that injustice can often attract as much attention as the latest shiny bit of political ephemera.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.