Their theory of simulation is wrong and baseless nonsense - Reality exists
Schwabach 3 (Aaron Schwaback @ Jefferson School of Law - Professor of Law and Director of Center for Global Legal Studies, J.D., University of California at Berkeley Published : 2003, <jonah> <IKS> “Kosovo: Virtual War and International Law,” DOA: 7-8-16, pages 1-21)
Baudrillard presents fewer problems of interpretation; his word is simulacrum (simulacre), which he uses in more or less the same sense, albeit with more elaboration, that it is ordinarily used.10 Academics are often criticized for over-reliance on opaque jargon. In comparison to many of his compatriots and their American emulators, Baudrillard indulges in jargon only sparingly. For the most part, he writes the most arrant nonsense in a clear, readily accessible style. His basic point is that the Gulf War was not a war but the simulacrum of a war; it happened not on the battlefield but on television. All of the traditional trappings of the buildup to war were presented, even grotesquely exaggerated, on television; at the end, however, we (the audience) were deprived of the final battle, left with neither victory for the Allies nor defeat for Saddam Hussein. In light of the bold promise of the book’s title, this is rather disappointing. Rather than arguing unequivocally that the entire war was a fraud perpetrated upon the television-viewing public, Baudrillard is simply nattering on again about simulacra. (At one point, though, he does suggest that “[o]ne is reminded of Capricorn One,” a movie about a government conspiracy to fake a Mars landing in a film studio and present it to the public as news.)11 Baudrillard, after all, is a man who, like his compatriot and predecessor Descartes, spends an inordinate amount of time wondering whether he exists. Unlike Descartes, however, he is not convinced that he exists merely because he thinks that he does. His identity, and that of everything and everyone else, is lost in a kaleidoscope of endlessly precessing simulacra that ultimately preclude the existence of any baseline reality. The Gulf War is not then real or unreal in any absolute sense, because there is no ultimate “reality.” It is simply less real than some things and more real than others. (Baudrillard draws many comparisons between “events” in the war and television commercials, for example.) The Gulf War (or simulacrum of war) is thus at least as real as international law, and by extension so is the Kosovo war; I shall therefore have to continue writing about all three. Baudrillard begins by asserting that “It might have been supposed that the defection of the Eastern Bloc would have opened up new spaces of freedom for war by unlocking deterrence. Nothing of the sort[.]”12 Baudrillard, writing these words at the beginning of 1991,13 was simply too impatient. As the world has since learned to its dismay, the defection of the Eastern Bloc and subsequent breakup of the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia has opened up a great number of new spaces of freedom for war, most notably in the expression of the ethnic conflicts previously repressed by authoritarian Communist regimes. Baudrillard himself would undoubtedly deplore the idea that the facts of his life might be responsible for his opinions. But his reactions on such topics as America and superpower conflict (and, as we shall see later, Arabs and Islam) are often surprisingly conventional for a person of his age, gender and nationality. Baudrillard was born in Reims in 1929.14 He would thus have been three or four years old when Hitler came to power, fifteen during the liberation of France, and sixteen when World War II ended. The bilateral Allied/Axis conflict was almost immediately replaced with a similar conflict between the more or less free-market countries of the West and the communist countries of the Soviet bloc. As a result, it is perhaps natural that Baudrillard would see a world with two opposing ideological camps as a prerequisite for war, or at least for war of the sort to which he is accustomed. At the time of communism’s collapse, he found it difficult to believe in the possibility of war in a post-Soviet world. By the time Baudrillard opined that the collapse of the Eastern bloc had opened up no new spaces of freedom for war, in fact, Croatia and Slovenia had already begun to make secessionist noises; six months later the first of Yugoslavia’s ethnic cleansing wars would begin. The Romanian revolution (or its simulacrum) had already taken place, as Baudrillard repeatedly acknowledges, after his fashion. 15 Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait could have been designed as a test case for the role of the United States in the post-Cold War world, as the first major act of territorial aggression in which the response of the Soviet Union (which itself would not last out the year) was more or less insignificant. Thus, simulacrum or not, the Gulf War was important historically. Baudrillard himself says, somewhat inconsistently in light of his other conclusions, that “what is at stake in this one is war itself: its status, its meaning, its future.”16 Much of what strikes Baudrillard as different about the Gulf War, though, is actually not new at all. For example, he sees the role of hostages as one of the Gulf War’s novel qualities: “The hostage has taken the place of the warrior. He has become the principal actor, the simulacral protagonist, or rather, in his pure inaction, the protagoniser of non-war.”17 Later, in Kosovo, the Serbian government would make an entire civilian population hostage. Yet the use of hostages in war, even on this scale, is hardly new; warring parties have always viewed hostages “as exchange value and liquidity.”18 Using hostages as human shields and bargaining chips is as old as war itself. It is when Baudrillard likens the plight of the audience to the plight of the hostages, though, that he begins to exhibit the indifference to human suffering for which he has so often been criticized.19 He writes that “all of us [are] information hostages on the world media stage….20 We are already all strategic hostages in situ; our site is the screen on which we are virtually bombarded day by day, even while serving as exchange value.”21 It is this element of the concept of simulacral war that is most difficult to accept. The difference between the hostage and the viewer should be obvious even to one who affects to disbelieve in his own existence; the viewer can simply turn off the television and thus escape his or her predicament. Nor do the viewers have significant “exchange value,” unless the governments concerned would discontinue the charade of war if they thought no one was watching, or unless the simulacrum exists only to the degree it is perceived. Thus the claim that “[t]he complement of the unconditional simulacrum in the field is to train everyone in the unconditional reception of broadcast simulacra” makes sense only if one also accepts that the simulacrum experienced by the viewer is identical to that experienced by the viewed. Those who believe in the reality of human suffering are likely to react to this idea with a certain amount of hostility, however. This reaction can only be exacerbated by the assertion that “it is [the hostages’] virtual death that is at issue, not their real death.