Baudrillard more wrong than he is right and lacks empirical validity
Rojek and Turner 93(Chris Rojek is a Professor of Sociology at City University. He has held Professorships since 1994 at The University of Staffordshire; Nottingham Trent University and Brunel University, West London. He is the author of 14 solo authored books, 12 edited and co-edited books and over 50 refereed articles.
and Brian S. Turner is a British and Australian sociologist., 1992, Forget Baudrillard?, Introduction, https://monoskop.org/images/0/0a/Rojek_Chris_Turner_Bryan_Forget_Baudrillard_1993.pdf)
Should we the regret the dazzling ascent of this writer in the Anglo-American world over the last decade? Certainly if the quality of a writer in the social sciences is to be assessed only by the validity of his or her propositions there is reason for regretting Baudrillard’s success. Baudrillard has been wrong—spectacularly wrong—about a lot of things. One thinks of his prediction of the impossibility of the Gulf war; his assertion that America is already utopia; his reactionary thesis that the strength of the feminine is seduction; his eccentric defence of the concert against quadrophonic sound which is predicated in the argument that Mozart was never intended to be heard through electronic systems of reproduction; and his unsupported statement that the body has become a mere extension of network television. And one thinks of these things casually, without systematically sifting through the careening waves of Baudrillard’s prose for other hostages to fortune or bad prophecies. In short, Baudrillard fails the validity test. However, it is by no means clear that validity is the only or even the most important criterion to assess the significance of an author’s work. Other criteria such as courage and sympathy are also relevant. In these respects Baudrillard is on stronger ground. The success of his publications in the English-speaking world since the 1980s suggests that his main themes of simulation and the seductiveness of consumer culture have found sympathy with a large audience of readers. Baudrillard may be wrong more often than he is right, but he has unquestionably struck the appropriate mood with which to approach questions of consumer culture.