Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Baudrillard’s defenders are mere propagandists that reduce their own scholarship to accumulation.

Horrocks 95(Christopher Horrocks, Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Design at Kingston University, August 16th 1995, Baudrillard and the Millennium[Postmodern Encounters], Beyond the Millennium: Anti-Baudrillard, the Vital Illusion and the Return of the Mirror People, pf 78-80)

Beyond the Millennium: AntiBaudrillard, the Vital Illusion and the Return of the Mirror People It is beside the point to condemn Jean Baudrillard for either spurning the tasks of rational and ethical judgement set by philosophers, or for his 'failure' to account for real human injustice, misery and oppression. Christopher Norris, Douglas Kellner, Alex Callinicos and a host of other writers in the Kantian or Marxist tradition have taken 58 Baudrillard to task, accusing his 'trash-theory' of being part of a modernist sensibility that substitutes art for philosophy, value for truth, image for reality, or Baudelaire for Kant."? Yet people do support Baudrillard's right to comment on our condition. For example, sociologist Zygmunt Bauman has attacked those rationalist critics of Baudrillard who assume that criticism only carries weight if one's feet are set on the rock of absolute and universal truth. These critics are always the last to claim that their stance is part of historical, social and mundane transformations. 78 As Chris Rojek notes, Baudrillard's tone and style is hardly one of indifference or happy consumerism. Rather, Baudrillard writes like 'a man who is strapped to the mast of the pathological society, who sees everything without illusions and who accepts that there is no cure around the corner';" In fact, Baudrillard himself puts forward his critics' standard complaints. These apostles of reality and truth, he says, claim that he is monstrous for discrediting reality while there are so many in the world who find even existence difficult; that he fails to attack affluence on behalf of the poor; that he disparages class struggle when there are those who have not had their revolution; or that he insults feminism and human rights when many have not yet acquired those rights. Baudrillard sees, however, that these good intentions disguise a contempt. In phrasing reality as a version of life insurance or a human right and, worse, assuming that people place hope only in the visible proofs of their existence ('a plaster-saint realism'), such critics take them for naive and feeble-minded. This contempt simply reflects the desire of the propagandists of reality to reduce their own lives to an accumulation of facts, evidence, causes and effects. 'Well-ordered resentment always begins at home', Baudrillard concludes. 80

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.