Multiple studies prove you’re wrong about people enjoying suffering and that images are necessary for action
Kyriakidou 21 (Maria, Senior Lecturer at the School of Journalism, Media and Culture, “The Audience of Human Communication”, 2021, ‘er’)
makes a psycho claim that baudrillard debaters unconsciously distance themselves from suffering through these args. probably the funniest card i’ve ever cut.
Researching the audience of suffering Limited but growing empirical research on audience responses to mediated suffering has been predominantly inspired by the reception paradigm of audience studies, whereby media viewers and users are approached as actively constructing meaning and interpreting media messages through various degrees of involvement and positioning in relation to the media (Livingstone, 1998; Morley, 1980, 1992). Given their qualitative nature, these studies have been small-scale, in-depth explorations of viewers’ reactions to mediated suffering. They have employed a variety of methods, such as focus groups, interviews and diaries. They have predominantly studied how audiences relate to news stories of suffering (Höijer, 2004; Huiberts & Joye, 2017; Kyriakidou, 2011) and, less often, to suffering witnessed through non-news programmes (Ong, 2015b; Scott, 2014); very few studies have explicitly studied audience engagement with humanitarian campaigns (Seu, 2003; 2010; von Engelhardt & Jansz, 2014). In her seminal work on the topic, Höijer explored audience reactions to the ‘discourse of global compassion’ constructed by the media through the reporting of humanitarian crises, wars and political conflicts and their innocent victims (Höijer, 2004). Her research, based on empirical material gathered through interviews and focus groups in Norway and Sweden, studied viewers’ reactions to media reports of war and violent news and concluded that compassion is most often directed to particular images of suffering and varies in its forms and expressions. Höijer concludes by describing the complexity of audience responses to suffering as ‘a twosided effect of global compassion on the one hand, and ignorance and compassion fatigue on the other’ expressed through ‘different forms of compassion as well as different forms of indifference’ (Höijer, 2004, p. 528). Indifference mostly reflected a critical stance and suspicion of media texts as either propagandistic or reflecting sensationalist, nationalistic mindsets, as well as overfamiliarity with images of suffering. Compassion, on the other hand, can be ‘tender-hearted’, ‘blamefilled’, ‘shame-filled’ and ‘powerlessness-filled’, according to Höijer. Interestingly, although the author acknowledges a variety of affective responses here, such as indignation or guilt, these are all described as being expressions of the same emotion, namely compassion. Focusing on the audience of humanitarian appeals, Seu also employed focus groups in a UK-based study of audience responses to NGO campaigns and news stories of human rights violations (Seu, 2003; 2010). Her analysis, focusing on the issue of audience (in)action and drawing upon the principles of psychology, psychoanalysis and rhetoric, illustrates the different ways people discursively distance themselves from the suffering of others and justify their unresponsiveness to human rights appeals. Scepticism about NGOs, their messages and international aid generally are given as reasons for such distancing. Cohen and Seu (2002, p. 189) describe such argumentative strategies as a ‘vocabulary of denial’ serving to avoid moral responsibility for witnessed suffering. Desensitisation, Seu argues, is a ‘defense’ mechanism against the realisation that ‘our social responsibility and human compassion, for whatever reason, do not stretch enough to getting us involved’ (Seu, 2003, p. 191). In a large-scale, UK-based study, Martin Scott (2014) combined focus group discussions with diaries, whereby participants were asked to log their daily media engagement. This research design allowed the author to move beyond the news genre and explore the mediation of distant suffering more broadly, including through other, factual television programmes. Influenced by Boltanski’s work, Scott analysed his material through the perspective of the options for action and emotion available to the viewers. He found substantial evidence of indifference to mediated encounters with distant suffering, particularly among young participants, as well as what he describes as ‘solitary enjoyment’, whereby research participants positioned themselves as observers of others’ suffering, devoid of any moral obligation to act (Scott, 2014, p. 13). An equally common type of engagement among participants was a tendency to evaluate media texts in terms of their accuracy and informational value (Scott, 2014, p. 10). Feelings of anger and indignation, per Boltanski’s topic of denunciation, were rather limited (Scott, 2014, p. 11). Given that participants seemed to be more emotionally involved with documentaries and current affairs programmes (Scott, 2014, p. 18), Scott’s study confirms Chouliaraki’s argument that media texts that represent suffering in its complexity and humanise the victims are necessary for constructing options for action and emotion on the part of the viewer (Chouliaraki, 2006).