Invoking simulacra is a capitalist ploy to distract from materialism
Schwabach 3 (Aaron Schwaback @ Jefferson School of Law - Professor of Law and Director of Center for Global Legal Studies, J.D., University of California at Berkeley Published : 2003, <jonah> <IKS> “Kosovo: Virtual War and International Law,” DOA: 7-8-16, pages 1-21)
Although this theme has attained the status of a cliche, one carefullydeveloped depiction is that in Joe Haldeman’s novel Forever Peace.78 The story’s protagonist, Julian Class, is a University of Texas professor and U.S. Army sergeant who spends ten days each month remotely operating a military robot metonymically (and ironically) called a soldierboy. Together Class and the soldierboy form a cyborg – a concept often linked in fiction and criticism with problems of identity. 79 Class, in the person of the soldierboy, fights against third-world guerrillas who, unlike him, are actually present. In one disturbing scene, he and his fellow soldiers discuss having killed two ten-year-old girls who fired upon the soldierboys.80 The girls could not have inflicted serious damage on the robot, and, of course, could not have injured Class or his fellow operators, who were far away and safe at the time. The scene could have been written in response to Baudrillard’s solipsistic view of virtual war as nothing more than non-intersecting simulacra – for Baudrillard, the simulacral war that the “Americans” experienced never mirrored that experienced by Saddam Hussein: “[T]he two adversaries did not even confront each other face to face, the one lost in its virtual war won in advance, the other buried in its traditional war lost in advance.”81 Haldeman’s reader, however, is left with the horrified awareness that, while Class’s war is a simulacrum, the little girl’s death is real. Inhabiting worlds of simulacra is a luxury enjoyed by academics from wealthy countries, like Jean Baudrillard and Julian Class, one of whom may be no more and no less real than the other. Those who actually risk death in war, though, enjoy no such luxury, but must believe in the reality of war and their own existence.