Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Baudrillard’s theory essentializes and valorizes the feminine and reproduces explicit binaries that subjugates and undermines women

A Keith Goshorn, critical theorist, associate professor of sociology at colgate university, Baudrillard: A Critical Reader, edited by Douglas Kellner, 1994, pg. 258-260

Yet more crucial than the above general considerations should be an examination of Baudrillard’s rather careless employment of a category of “the feminine,” particularly in constructing one of his central theoretical figures, the notion of seduction. this usage of “the feminine” here and elsewhere in his writing surely appears, on the surface, to be risking a narrowly essentialized definition of the term, and one drawn from the social postures of a previous century at that. Worse, he might be said to be participating in a continued “metaphorization” of the feminine,3 which marks the distancing and objectification of women as Other-ness. Seen in this light, his posture would only be typical of a long history of male philosophers trying to “place into discourse” an idealized or imaginary “feminine” while remaining relatively indifferent to or ignorant of the status of the “real” women around them. Furthermore, can he also fairly be charged with employing an outmoded binary and oppositional sense of masculine/feminine polarity — even though he is obviously trying to excavate through the theory of seduction a strategy which, even in the words of his harshest critics, seems to ... . subvert ... fixed dualities between masculine and feminine”4? The charges of his allegedly essentialized usage of femininity (and masculinity) must be weighed not against any possible ameliorations by elder male generational oversight (if it is indeed only that), but against the possibility that his intention has been rather to deconstruct the historical function of the category itself and how it has supposedly been used. From this perspective, his aim is not primarily to create a discourse of female submission, but to develop a counterfactual sub-discourse which set an overt agenda by which masculine prerogatives have only constructed themselves in defensive and insecure postures against a naturally superior female order and its dominant set of “secret” goals. While any, even preliminary, understanding of his precarious position here will require some defining extrapolations of what a deliberately uncipherable and non-representative theory of seduction represents, a fair-minded critique will require some speculation as to what purpose the author intended by such a theory as well as a judgment of its results. One must then determine what advantages and disadvantages Baudrillard has given himself in trying to counter the tyranny of the rationalist productivist ethic with language drawn from a long-passed epoch rife with sexist and “aristocratic overtones. And, finally, we can ask whether he may be wisely obliged to abandon an unworkable theory of seduction in his attempt to formulate a subversive counter-weight to the dominating mode of capitalist productivism. And, regardless of our judgment on any of the above, at this point in time, our attention is merited by any theorist who undertakes to question and challenge, even indirectly, the cultural foundations of the religion of “free market economy” which, along with its semiotic viruses of commercial promotionalism and the commodification of discourse, have so thoroughly naturalized themselves into nearly all aspects of contemporary life, especially its discourse of “sexuality.” Baudrillard deserves further scrutiny from feminists most particularly here for his attention to the exchange value basis of traditional sexuality and its reflection of capitalist objectification, paradoxically reproduced by its emphasis on individualist “subjectivity” or subjective “individualism.” For this sexuality as feminists have known all along, is tainted as a sub-set derivative of what Baudrillard calls “the abjection of free enterprise.” Although it is unavoidably necessary in addressing the issues at stake in this essay to use the conventional distinctions of “male” critics and “female” critics, I do not intend to suggest in any way a grouping of qualities around or inherent to either. Likewise, I do not mean to imply anything necessarily synonymous between “women” and “feminists,” even if these two do occasionally get thrown together here. Furthermore, it should be obvious by now that to be a feminist is not to automatically belong to one gender or the other. Indeed, one of the foremost points I hope to establish is that Baudrillard’s continuance in identifying women only with certain universalized “feminine” qualities is a severely detrimental limitation to the overall more-radical intentions of his theoretical project.6 This becomes evident when we begin to see the contradictions that result from his acceptance of the Freudian axiom of a single, masculine libido theory of sexuality implicit in his early writings on seduction, in contrast to his later theorizations of entering a condition of transsexuality which begin to resonate with the more progressive feminist notions of gender as a culturally learned performativity. His notion of transsexuality is but an aspect of a greater cultural movement of transvestism, which is the term he utilizes to characterize the implosion of previous fixed cultural polarities into what he sees as our current state of indeterminacy.7 Ultimately, more is at stake here than simply deciding whether Baudrillard has made sexist remarks, held onto essentialized notions of women and “the feminine,” or has been a deliberately antagonistic provocateur of feminism and the social movements for women’s “liberation.” What finally matters in the resolution of such questions is whether significantly new currents of thought have arisen which have possibly erased the need or the basis for past antagonisms. The one thing which I would assert with some certainty at the outset is that both the adherents of the multiple strains of today’s feminism as well as the multiple adherents of Baudrillard’s theoretical project will be far better off if they can listen to and learn from each other. For the French theorist is no more a ‘traditional male’ than he is the embodment of his self-described ‘supreme femininity.’ And the most alert of today’s feminists no more see themselves as a group of non-liberated “autonomous feminine subjects” than they are a group of “non-seductive female phallocrats” as seen in the eyes of some of their detractors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.