Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Baudrillard’s critique of spectacle and images fails to trace the genealogy of such events ultimately reifying the colonization of everyday life.

Jelly-Schapiro 18 (Eli, Associate Professor of English at the University of South Carolina, “Security and Terror: American Culture and the Long History of Colonial Modernity,” This Is Our Threnody”: Writing History as Catastrophe, (2018), 6/27/22 - FI)

The conjoined critiques of spectacle, exception, and imperial capital, though, are unevenly revelatory of the colonial essence and history of contemporary culture and politics. This unevenness is an effect of theory’s symptomatic nature—the ways in which theory often echoes the form of its critical object. The works I critically engage in this chapter are exemplary instances of this formal echo. In their critiques of spectacle, Jean Baudrillard and Slavoj Žižek reproduce the ahistoricity of the image, leaving untraced the genealogical routes that connect commodity ascendance in the postcolonial metropole to the pure articulation of commodity rationality in the colony. In their theorizations of bare life and the state of exception, meanwhile, Giorgio Agamben and Judith Butler affirm the exceptionalism of the War on Terror’s political technologies. Finally, Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri’s critique of an emergent imperial order adopts two abiding tropes of the “globalization” concept: the assumption of an imminent or achieved planetarity—the disappearance of the “outside” that is essential to colonial rationality—and the assumption that the defining political forms of this globalism originate in the advanced capitalist world. Spectacle, Capital, Terror As theorized by Theodor Adorno and others, the mass violence of the twentieth century redefined the aesthetic and political implications of the sublime. Kant and Burke recognized that performances of political violence could produce the sublime, but they reserved the term “nature” for the non-human world. Writing in the eighteenth century, they did not see, or anticipate, the profound reification of social life under capital—the ways in which historically contingent social relations, and the violence inherent therein, are rendered by the mythos of capital as natural. In the context of this “second nature,” the sublime acquires a different resonance and effect. Spectacular instances of political violence, and indeed the relentless spectacle of commodity culture, do not permit the second moment in Kant’s dynamic sublime, wherein human reason and rationality reasserts its dominance over the irrationality of nature—because the irrationality of “second nature” violence is inextricable from rationality itself, and because there is no longer a position of safe remove, an outside, from which one can regard and redeem the sublime. 4 The naturalization of commodity rationality was a key concern of the thinkers of the Situationist International. Guy Debord published his seminal Society of the Spectacle in 1967. Debord named, in that book’s title and in its interior contents, a new form of capitalism based on the subjection of ever more realms of human social life to the rationality of the market. In so doing he described one of the defining characteristics of neoliberalism before the neoliberal era had properly begun. (Most historians of neoliberalism locate its inception in the early 1970s.) The prescience of Debord’s critique, and the endurance of the state of affairs he highlighted and foretold, has ensured that the Society of the Spectacle remains a relevant text, one with much to say about the culture and techniques of contemporary capital accumulation. The “colonization of everyday life” was enabled by the ascent of the image—as a commodity in itself and as a screen that conceals, like a fetish, the reality of capitalist social relations. Debord’s use of the term “colonization”—and Henri Lefebvre’s echo of it—might be read as proposing an obfuscatory analogy between the radically different modalities of commodity rationality in the colony and metropole. His choice of metaphor, though, evinces the historical articulation of, rather than collapses the distance between, colony and metropole. Invoking “colonization” rather than simply “commoditization” evokes the dialectical relation between the violence of extractive industry in the space of the colony and the saturation by the commodity form of all spheres of human social life in the consumerist societies of the overdeveloped world. It points, in other words, toward the history of colonial violence that conditions—is synchronically and diachronically connected to—cultures of alienation and exploitation in the postcolonial metropole Reflecting the televisual glare of the Twin Towers’ collapse, several widely cited theoretical texts composed in the near aftermath of September 11 summon Debord’s critique—notably Jean Baudrillard’s The Spirit of Terrorism (2002), Slavoj Žižek’s Welcome to the Desert of the Real (2002), and the Retort group’s Afflicted Powers (2004). The contemporary critique of spectacle confronts the same theoretical aporia negotiated by Debord: How to highlight the primacy of the image without submitting to its power? How to reveal the ubiquity of commodity culture without reinforcing its omnipotence and reproducing it’s a historicity? The Retort group observes that “the colonization of everyday life” is simply “‘globalization’ turned inward.” 5 The contemporary critique of spectacle, I want to argue, mimics rather than resists this inward turning. The violence of spectacle expresses itself in both subjective and objective forms. Subjective violence, as Žižek has outlined this distinction, refers to “violence performed by a clearly identifiable agent”—the violence that shows up on the evening news, the violence that disrupts the peaceful workings of everyday social and political order. 6 Objective violence, by contrast, refers to the often-invisible violence of the system itself—the pervasive and perpetual violence of capital in its globalized form. Spectacular instances of subjective violence serve one of two contradictory purposes. The dramatic car accident viewed by millions on YouTube distracts from rather than directs our attention to the slow ecological violence of automobile culture. But the logic of the terrorist attack—and indeed, as Retort cites, that of “the ruined small farmer from South Korea, slashing his arteries in defiance on the barricades at Cancun” 7 —avows that another form of subjective violence is possible, one that will cut through the thick screens of fetishism and reification. The potentiality of the “image-event” in exposing and resisting the objective violence of commodity culture is one central concern of the contemporary critique of spectacle. “The events in New York,” Baudrillard writes in The Spirit of Terrorism , “have radicalized the relation of the image to reality. Whereas we were dealing before with an uninterrupted profusion of banal images and seamless flow of sham events, the terrorist act in New York has resuscitated both images and events.” 8 The meeting of image and event, though, is not seamless. “At the same time that [images] exalt the event,” Baudrillard contends, “they also take it hostage. They serve to multiply it to infinity and . . . are a diversion and neutralization. . . . The image consumes the event, in the sense that it absorbs it and offers it for consumption.” 9 The force of the real event is correlated to the symbolic power of its proliferation as image. But the reduction of the event to its image denies the experience of the event as reality. Baudrillard elaborates this paradox by suggesting that the destruction of the Twin Towers elucidated the contest between, and entwined nature of, reality and fiction. For many observers, Baudrillard notes, September 11, 2001, represented the “resurgence of the real . . . in an allegedly virtual universe” (a resurgence that corresponded with “the resurrection of history beyond its proclaimed end”). Baudrillard is wary of this reading, however, and insists instead that if reality appears, in the event of the Twin Towers’ collapse, to overtake fiction, “this is because it has absorbed fiction’s energy, and has itself become fiction.” 10 The image precedes and surpasses the real event: “Rather than the violence of the real being there first, and the frisson of the image being added to it, the image is there first, and the frisson of the real is added.” 11 The image delivers the real. In other words, the violence of September 11 does not represent the return of history or the return of the real. It represents, rather, the triumph of the symbolic. In Baudrillard’s reading, the image-event of September 11 was empty of political content. The political aims of its actors, the historical forces from which it emerged and to which it responds—all of this is eclipsed by the image. Every replay of the towers falling serves to further evacuate the event of its historical and political meaning. Yet in making this observation so central to his account, Baudrillard finds himself stuck in something of a critical cul-de-sac. His emphasis on September 11 as spectacle—and his corresponding neglect of the concrete social relations within which the spectacle operates—serves to reinforce rather than resist the fetishism of the image. The question his account ultimately prompts, then, is how to “[preserve] intact the unforgettable incandescence of the image” 12 without being blinded by it. This is not to condemn or dismiss Baudrillard’s essay—a slim and narrow volume that does not aspire to any kind of comprehensive reading of global politics—but to shed light upon the ways in which the dominance of the image is reprised in the moment of critique.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.