Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is quantum holography. That challenges the tautological ontology of the Newtonian narrative.

Chengxin Pan 20, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Australia, 2020, “Enfolding wholes in parts: quantum holography and International Relations,” European Journal of International Relations 2020, Vol. 26(S1) 14–38

Despite its name, International Relations (IR) has long been predicated on a Newtonian substantialist ontology of things, rather than an ontology of relations, which are “the important missing dimension in most theories of IR” (Wight, 2006: 296). In recent years, IR’s “deep Newtonian slumber” (Ruggie, 1998: 194) has been disturbed by a “relational turn” (Bousquet and Curtis, 2011; Jackson and Nexon, 1999; Kavalski, 2018; McClurg and Young, 2011; Neumann, 2013; Nexon, 2010; Nordin et al., 2019; Nordin and Smith, 2018; Qin, 2018; Shih, 2016; Trownsell et al., 2019). Challenging two versions of Newtonian substantialism: atomism (individualism) and structuralism (structuralistsubstantialism) (Zanotti, 2017; see also Wendt, 1999: 26), the gist of this turn is that the fundamental reality is not independent things, but relations. Focusing on “a relation between entities” (Jackson and Nexon, 2019: 584–585, emphases in original), the relational scholarship also departs from the agent-structure and level-of-analysis debates. Yet, despite this significant and welcome development, IR’s relational turn suffers several drawbacks. First, it lacks a clear conception of relations/relationality beyond often tautological definitions. Second, insisting on the temporal priority of relations over entities, much of the literature sidesteps an implicit “chicken-egg” dilemma between entities and relations. Further and more importantly, the relational turn has not yet seriously engaged with another important development in the social sciences in general and IR in particular, namely, the “quantum turn” (Keeley, 2007; Wendt, 2015), or according to Der Derian and Wendt (2020), a permanent quantum revolution. This neglect is both surprising and lamentable. Both turns share an anti-Newtonian stand, and as a “momentous shift in metaphysical outlook” (Seager, 2018: 5), quantum mechanics espouses a doctrine of relational holism “in an all pervasive way” (Teller, 1986: 71), which would make quantum theory a valuable source in IR’s relational quest. To be fair, at least in the IR context the neglect seems mutual. With few exceptions and some general references to relational ontology (e.g. Wendt, 2015; Fierke, 2017; Zanotti, 2017), the burgeoning quantum turn literature in IR has not focused extensively on relations either. Wendt’s pioneering work on quantum theory, for example, is driven primarily by the need to “reconcile consciousness and meaning with the material world” (Wendt, 2006: 218), though he acknowledges that quantum mechanics’ holistic and relational contribution is “a thematic that needs to be developed down the road” (Wendt, 2015: 35). Therefore, the gap between these two turns in IR calls for an explicit quantum relational perspective. This is what this article sets out to do, by offering, more specifically, a quantum holographic approach. The basic notion of holography is that an “object” is “part of the whole while it simultaneously contains the whole” (Van Daele, 2018: 651, emphases added).1 In quantum theory, the holographic principle promises a solution to the well-known tensions between atomic-level quantum physics and Albert Einstein’s planet-level theory of gravity by suggesting that the universe is a holographic projection: what appears on the surface (event horizon) of a black hole is encoded information about what is inside, “just as a two-dimensional hologram encodes a three-dimensional image” (Merali, 2013: 517). So far still largely alien to this field (few exceptions include Pan, 2018; Wendt, 2015), quantum holography adds value to IR in several important ways. First, as a specific form of relationality, quantum holography helps mitigate the existing definitional vagueness about relations. Second, instead of asserting relations’ priority over entities, quantum holography accentuates the ontological duality of relations and things. Avoiding the ontological chickenegg dilemma over which comes first, the duality proposition suggests that relations do not exist either before or after things; rather, relations are from the outset implicated or embodied in things. Relations-in-things are implicate relations that can be better understood through quantum mechanics, whereas things-in-relations (and relations-between-things) represent more classical understandings of relations as something external, compositional, and derivative. Third, quantum holography provides a deeper and more sophisticated understanding of relations, including whole-part relations and internal relations, which have not been adequately theorized in IR. Furthermore, its differentiation between explicate and implicate relations enables us to incorporate mainstream IR’s Newtonian ontology as a limiting case in a broader quantum relational ontology, rather than simply brush it aside.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.