Binarism is the cause of external conflict.
Chengxin Pan 20, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Australia, 2020, “Enfolding wholes in parts: quantum holography and International Relations,” European Journal of International Relations 2020, Vol. 26(S1) 14–38
This article situates itself between the relational turn in IR and the quantum turn in the social sciences (and lately in IR as well). Between the two turns, there has been a mutual neglect at the expense of a better defined and more operationalizable relational approach to IR. To address the gap, this article has outlined a quantum holographic ontology, which stipulates that parts are more than just parts in the conventional sense of the word, but are specifically enfolded wholes. Drawing on Bohm’s insights into wholeness and the implicate order, the article has introduced a set of new conceptual tools to IR in general and to the relational debate in particular, such as whole-part duality, enfoldment, unfoldment, implicate order, and explicate order. These tools help us rethink IR and many dominant IR concepts in some ontologically innovative ways, including the need to take wholeness in IR more seriously, a new emphasis on the holographic nature of the state, and the promises of this approach for explaining and mitigating difference and conflict in IR theory and practice. By way of conclusion, the article now briefly considers two ethical implications of quantum holography for IR. First, the holographic being/becoming for “parts” is immensely empowering, because it reveals that the parts, or previously assumed individual “selves,” are never alone in a frightening state of nature; rather, they are inescapably linked to and sustained by the whole/world: indeed, their holographicity means that they are the whole/world, merely on smaller scales. This should transform the way we think about our identity, interest, and security in a fundamentally relational and positive way, because in a holographically related world, there can be no inherent “Others” or “external” threats out there unless we consciously or subconsciously divide the world in binary terms and act accordingly. Second, holographic being/becoming entails holographic responsibility, which is an ethical commitment to the notion and practice of responsibility for all. By all we mean the whole and its various “parts,” including the smallest “components,” such as corals and insects. To the extent that they all ultimately share the same whole, all parts, large or small, are real or potential enfoldments of the whole. Their well-being, as an indicator of the well-being of the whole, matters to the whole and to each of its parts. Thus, responsibility for all means “care for all and do no harm.” In a holographically connected world, harm to “others” (even the smallest “others”) means inevitably harm to the whole, including the “self,” who necessarily enfolds the whole: here the example of the microplastics problem comes to mind. Cosmopolitanism has long held the idea that “harm to individuals [is] a moral problem for the world as a whole” (Linklater, 2002: 320), and quantum holography can enrich the relational ontology of cosmopolitanism and at the same time help it move beyond its narrow humanist focus.