Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Nation states are the cause of peace and promote regional unity.

Sebastiaan Laurens Metselaar 18, Graduate School of Seoul National University, International Cooperation, “A study on how modern nationalism can prevent imperialism from re-emerging,” February 2018, Seoul National University, https://s-space.snu.ac.kr/bitstream/10371/141693/1/000000151525.pdf

Though we do live in the most peaceful era of our time, we tend to forget how much more violent the world has used to be. These days, more people die of car crashes than being killed by wars or terrorism. We commemorate the wars and celebrate our independence, to continue the realization of what happened and to what extend we are capable of committing inhumane crimes. Whether internal state conflicts have been decreased since the end of World War II is debatable, but that clashes between states have decreased is undeniable. The succession of the League of Nations by the United Nations, provides one of the most powerful resistance to pull factors in keeping nations in check with regards to imperial ambitions. Obviously there were tensions during for example the Cold War and conflicts did break out between states, but in light of the historic time frame, it has never been this peaceful as it is today. No Roman or Ottoman empire can start a conquest, in fact, ever since the end of the last great war no country recognized by the United Nations has been conquered or wiped of the map. Even the superpowers today who have all the means for starting their imperial conquest have to take into account that such conquest are too costly to undertake (e.g. Russia and Crimea, China and Tibet). And despite that conflicts are still present; the United Nations does not only have the tools to interfere military wise (i.e. peacekeeping operations), but also the capabilities to sanction perpetrators. The United Nations might be far from perfect as power struggles within the system exist, causing nations among each other to differentiate in meaning and action. However, as long as it is in place, nations will rethink once more their behavior.

Thus, no country has attempted to conquer another nation ever since the end of the decolonization period. The rise of the nation has a causal relationship to the decline in interstate violence. Moreover, the nationalists in a country do not want to start an imperial conquest and make colonies, instead, they want the colonials out of their country. The nationstate as we know it today is deeper rooted in the emotions of the masses than any other previous political organization has achieved before. In order for nationalism to develop and for sovereignty to be claimed by the populace, a complete revision of the status quo was required.

As for Korea, the foundation of nationalism developed during the annexation by Japan and it was not strong enough to prevent the separation between the North and South. These days, South-Korea has probably one of the strongest forms of nationalism. The love for the flag and the (popular) culture, the remembrance of its past, all contribute to strong sense of horizontal connection. The best and most recent display of Korea’s nationalism were the regular massive protests, by the millions, opposed to the Korean president. The fear of the Korean people in the survey stated in the introduction are therefore overrated.

Not only have the costs of imperial warfare gone up, its profits also declined. Looking into the history of empires, the mere reason for expanding was to search for resources that could still the economic hunger for growth. Thus, most conquests were focusing on securing material wealth such as gold, silver, spices, cattle, but also slaves. These days, we all have access to a global market and as our traditional resources are getting exhausted, there is a shift in focus to for example renewable energy sources. So, not only war did war became less profitable, peace became more lucrative than ever.

Additionally, when we examine the historical developments starting from the cognitive revolution till present day, we can observe that we are moving toward unity. The reason for this observation is that we moved throughout history from many separate tribes and communities into the large nations covering territories today. We now share a mostly similar geopolitical system as the world has been divided into internationally recognized nations, we share a similar economic system (i.e. capitalist open market place), a similar legal system (i.e. international and human rights), and we use the same scientific system (scientist from all over the world share the same view about the structure of atoms or the treatment of tuberculosis). This applied to the transformation of nationalism too, it did not spread evenly across the globe. It was a phenomenon that slowly spread itself. Notably, nationalism is not the end station. After the dynasties transformed into what we call nations, we are now at the brink of a breakthrough of a new transformation, regionalism. Europe is ahead of this transformation, with the establishment of the European Union and its Schengen treaty of free movement. There are more regional blocks rising in the world, even within Africa. Though regionalism is experiencing some setbacks as we have seen with the Brexit and the rise of nationalistic movements, this form will at some point in time succeed nationalism and its pre-predecessor dynasticism. Whereas with nationalism we feel this horizontal comradeship with our own nationals, in regionalism we feel connected in a similar way with other nationals.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.