Humans are disentangled from nature. The idea of entanglement is intrinsically Newtonian.
Scott Hamilton 18, professor at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE), London, UK, “Securing ourselves from ourselves? The paradox of “entanglement” in the Anthropocene,” rime Law Soc Change 68, 579–595 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-017-9704-4
This article argues that an epoch defined by and through the action of anthropos, the human, does not represent an entanglement of humanity with things, nature, or the Earth. Instead, the Anthropocene illustrates and intensifies a profound separation or dis-entanglement of humanity from nature. It replaces what was once the primary and objective concern of security – i.e., survival, or avoiding death – with anthropos, the human being, as a new geological and spatiotemporal force to be problematized and secured in both the present and the future. Rather than protecting itself from physical threats in an external world, humanity now subsumes that world by making itself the simultaneous subject/object of security; an Archimedean point. With the catastrophic prognoses for the Anthropocene’s future making humanity’s temporal, ontological, and epistemological essence uncertain, a paradox forms: an existential discontinuity, in which humanity must secure itself in the future from itself in the present.
This “Paradox of the Anthropocene” forms an ontological insecurity that is evinced through the concept of “entanglement” now borrowed from quantum physics and applied to human/nature relations. As noted above, entanglement is commonly used as an expression emphasizing humanity’s enmeshment with, and hence its ethical responsibility towards, non-human forms of life and matter. However, although its complex understanding of space, time, and the nature of reality offers a quantum rejoinder to neo-Newtonian or “classical” understandings of physics, upon closer inspection ‘entanglement’ is found to replicate and exacerbate these same classical dynamics within Anthropocene discourses. The atomic scale and nature of “quantum” is so complex that any observation of nature in-itself is impossible, in that any knowledge of quantum always already presupposes human interference and involvement in nature [7]. This implies that security or morality in the Anthropocene cannot be derived from, nor based upon, the mathematical principles of entanglement alone. Rather, it is from humanity’s dis-entanglement – the gap or distance between our mathematical knowledge of entangled phenomena and the social world within which we as humans reside – from which ethics, norms, and values are derived. The danger lies not in promoting and demanding humanity’s ethical responsibility towards nature and Earth – a noble and essential task indeed – but in attributing these ethics to entanglement, thereby forgetting how it is only through a social and human world that forms of security and responsibility are made practicable and thinkable.
This article proceeds as follows: First, it provides a brief overview of how security and entanglement are commonly used and combined in scholarly literature. The Anthropocene’s “entanglement” claims are generally positioned as a new form of human/nature order in response to the destabilization of traditional subject/object binaries that outmoded logics of security were previously grounded upon. Second, it examines how a specific variant of security – “ontological security”, or the existential securing of a continuous sense of self – best exemplifies or situates security discourses surrounding the Anthropocene today. The success of the concept of the Anthropocene is an artifact or product of this profound new ontological (in)security. In an uncertain future, the Anthropocene provides a new ontological certainty and stable understanding of what humans as individuals, and as a species, have become: a planetary force [8]. Third, by examining the concept of quantum entanglement in greater detail, this article outlines how its version of anthropos is made always already present in a neo-Newtonian guise. By elevating itself to the status of a present and future global security problem, the human is neither entangled or entwined with nature, but only with its own classical knowledge of nature. Finally, the article concludes by outlining a possible solution to this paradox: to embrace humanity’s dis-entanglement from Nature as a social space, within which to recognize and act ethically against humanity’s catastrophic effects on the planet. This requires grasping the quantum lesson that humanity will never be fully enmeshed or entangled with Nature: “Thus even in science the object of research is no longer nature itself, but man’s investigation of nature. Here, again, man confronts himself alone” ([7], p.24).