Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff has asked us to negate it as a valuable enterprise – we say “No”.

Kroker 14 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, “Exits to the Posthuman Future”, Polity Press, Pages 202-204, 2014, MG)

Refusing to secrete itself in those bureaucratic institutions that produce mechanisms of domination (the clinic, the prison, the school), cynical ideology thrives by making a continuous spectacle of its presence. It is a line of flight, an intensity that doubles and redoubles its effects. When power becomes image, cynical truth is volatilized by the image repertoire. It knows only media effects. It migrates across different media. It changes state as it seeks points of maximal intensity for communication with a humiliated public. It is without history because it leaves no fixed electronic trail. Its truth-value depends precisely on its articulation of perspectives that strengthen movements towards panic insecurity and redemptive violence. While power aligns itself with knowledge, not ideology, cynical ideology aligns itself with virtual truth, not power. Privileging sacrificial death over the life of power, cynical ideology represents truth in its last decadent phase as a concept-fiction.

In the age of cynical ideology, everything has value only to the extent that it has “abuse value.” Heidegger recognized this. Understanding Nietzsche as the essential philosopher of completed nihilism, Heidegger drew the bitter ethical conclusions attendant upon the reduction of being to passive “standing reserve.” For Heidegger, the mood of completed nihilism will be the “malice of strife” that takes pleasure in the greater calculus of abuse value. Today, the theater of abuse value is ubiquitous: the rage of violence directed against the old, the poor, the young, the sick, the powerless, the disavowed, the unlivable. Political lying is itself a form of abuse value with the object of abuse being the rupturing of that deep connection between truth-saying and the responsibilities of democratic citizenship. When citizenship itself is made an object of abuse value (by manipulation of vote counts, by public lies, by panic fear), the essential ethical core of democracy is undermined. We're left finally with the terrorism of the image, a new form of nihilism suitable for the technological age in which ministrations of redemptive violence during the daylight hours are soothed away by the nighttime jokes of all the talk-show hosts. A moral equivalency of nothingness – organized state terrorism and diffuse media distraction as the basic political logic of a society of completed nihilism. This is not an image of Foucault's world of power. Nor is it Deleuze and Guattari's searing vision of lines of flight and points of intensity – becoming wolf-man, becoming maggot-man, becoming predator, becoming parasite. It is something new, still emergent, still articulating itself, still learning to speak, still growing in strength, still waiting to fully disclose itself – cynical ideology.

Nonetheless, there is much to be learned from Foucault's theory of power in terms of what resists power, what produces that fatal rupture in individual subjectivity that has the effect of overcoming fear and stirring again the passionate desire for freedom. That this is an elemental human desire tracing a larger arc of history across countries, whole continents, until it encompasses global consciousness is indisputable. Everywhere in the past, as in the present and future, power as domination meets its equal in the stubborn, always ethically recalcitrant, presence of an individual subjectivity that says “No,” and thereby marks one individual at a time, one body at a time, one refusal at a time the furthest limits of domination. Foucault knew this. It is everywhere in his work from the repressed history of erotic passion that makes of The History of Sexuality an emblematic study of the entwinement of passion and freedom in the politics of the body to the tortured revolt against the body of the king and its ceremonial punishment that introduces Discipline and Punish. Whether in the “grey genealogy of power” or in his eloquent reflections on the history of madness or the troubled histories of medicine, knowledge, and aesthetics, there is always the presence of the individual act of dissent, the philosophical heresy, the medical rupture, the lover's forbidden embrace that constitutes, at first in minor note and then, with gathering strength, an irresistible momentum towards generalized discursive change.

Foucault may have been the master of discourse analysis, the theorist who brought into the light of day the alliance of regulations, prohibitions, modes of thought, public rhetoric that, taken together, comes to be known as the discourse of power, the discourse of the intelligible body, the discourse of sexuality, the discourse of punishment. But for all that, the seduction of Foucault's thought, that which has made of his philosophical life a haunting marker denoting a larger shift in cultural sensibility, was the simple fact that, while Foucault's theory of power may have described its historical machinations in grisly, meticulous detail, the lasting legacy of his thought is that his theory of power is also its own undoing. For no sooner does Foucault remind us that power is a network, that it circulates, that it operates as a “relation of force,” that it actually produces subjectivity, then his theory of power seems to shudder to a halt, to maintain its stability only on the basis of a violent internal repression. Ironically, if Foucault could argue time and again that resistance to power is one of the fundamental conditions for the preservation of power, that power feeds on its oppositions, that is only to say that everywhere in Foucault's thought there is acute awareness of that which lies outside and at one remove from the reach of power: that which is prohibited, excluded, disavowed, rendered unknowable, perhaps even unlivable, by the discourse of power.

Many commentators on Foucault have grasped the fundamental truth of his insights concerning the doubled nature of power. For example, Judith Butler's The Psychic Life of Power represents a sustained meditation on the dialectic of affirmations and prohibitions marking the discourse of power. Wendy Brown's States of Injury does much the same, this time though tracing the doubled dialectic of power as it works its way through the contemporary psycho-geography of political ressentiment. In chapter and verse, Butler and Brown are faithful to Foucault's teachings concerning power, namely that the regimes of intelligibility required by power always mark the unmarkable, specifically that which must be made unknowable, unlivable, unsustainable so that power can exist. Indeed, more than a historical record of the outlawed sexualities, the forbidden genders, the transgressionary crossings that mark the limits of power, the theoretical reflections of theorists such as Butler and Brown have the added measure of following the trace of Nietzsche in Foucault.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.