Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Debates about transatlantic relations are good

Franke and Hofferberth 21 (Ulrich Franke and Matthias Hofferberth, *PhD in political science, **PhD, Associate Professor in the Department of Political Science and Geography. 2021 ISA Annual Convention, "From Transatlantic Relations to World Order: Reconstructing Beliefs as Rules for Action", 4/6/2021, http://colfa.utsa.edu/polisci-geography/docs/Franke__Hofferberth_ISA_2021_final.pdf, accessed on 7/21/2022)//gideon

More specifically, past decades have produced a global power shift away from transatlantic relations as the product of Western, state-driven foreign policy in two respects. As to the first, whether or not one believes the assertion of the dissolution of the Soviet Union provided a unipolar moment for the United States in the early 1990s (Mearsheimer 2019, Ikenberry 2014), undoubtedly the most significant constituent and a sine qua non of any transatlantic relations, new powers have emerged in the meantime and affect these relations significantly. On a global level, in view of the massive increase in military spending, the People’s Republic of China is the first to be mentioned, but on a regional level, Russia, India, Brazil, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and, certainly in a different fashion but nevertheless relevant, the European Union, another important constituent part of the so-called West, have all expressed different perspectives on and visions of world order recently (Acharya 2017). Collectively, global power shifts in favor of non-Western states can certainly be considered a consensus within International Relations (IR). The same holds for the assumption that this is accompanied by a – relative – loss of importance of the West, specifically in light of President Trump’s disregard for multilateralism and the values of the liberal order as such. Second, power on the international scene understood as the capacity to have an impact on people’s lives whether they want it or not, is also shifted to and increasingly exerted by so-called non-state actors and within intergovernmental organizations (Avant, Finnemore, and Sell 2010). This includes advocacy groups claiming moral high grounds in global governance as well as multinational corporations, particularly to but not exclusively from the technology sector (Alphabet/Google, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Microsoft to name but a few). - 3 - Against this backdrop of a double power shift away from the West and away from states, we do not believe that the declining relative relevance of transatlantic relations as the internal relationship of the West diminishes its relevance as an object of IR research. Rather, assuming discursive importance as a reference object and as political practice, we assume actors in and of transatlantic relations respond to these challenges and thereby either reproduce or develop new aspects of said relations. For one thing, we do not assume a zero-sum approach to power. Under the condition of an understanding of power as the enforcement of rules, for instance, the relative loss of power of a political entity can go hand-in-hand with the entity striving to enforce a greater number of rules in absolute terms than before. What these rules-as-visions are about, then, remains important – regardless of the fact that others also (increasingly) have power and enforce (an even more growing number of) rules. Moreover, it can be observed that in case of positional differences between the governments of the U.S. on the one hand and (some) European states on the other hand, major crises and the end of transatlantic relations are always proclaimed very quickly (and alarmistically) – by politicians, journalists, but also by IR scholars. Crisis and catharsis, at least, seem to be recurrent narratives of transatlantic relations, often originating unreflectively within a hybrid discourse of practitioners and think tanks, often derived from the notion that a new U.S. president approaches transatlantic relations in a different light.1 The inherent presentism of think tank thinking and political practice aside, transatlantic relations are thus still a much-noticed object of public debate and consideration as they remain an issue quite affectively occupied and connected to normative assumptions, in the West as well as beyond. To examine transatlantic relations thus also seems promising from this point of view.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.