Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Regulation is key to solve the consequences of surveillance capitalism – only working with both tech and regulations can solve

Landwehr, Borning & Wulf 21 – [Marvin Landwehr is a Ph.D. student for Pluralist Economics and Socio-Informatics at the University of Siegen, Alan Borning is a Professor Emeritus in the Paul G Allen School of Computer Science & Engineering at the University of Washington, Volker Wulf is a professor in Information Systems and the director of the Media Research Institute at the University of Siegen; 12/19/21; “Problems with surveillance capitalism and possible alternatives for IT infrastructure”; https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/1369118X.2021.2014548?src=recsys; accessed 7/19/22; Lowell-JL]

Turning now to what could be done, one goal should be to limit the damage done by the surveillance capitalism business model, while still retaining key benefits of the services it provides. But if possible, we would like to move beyond damage control and support positive visions of how IT can better support people and communities. Crafting and deploying such solutions is an exceedingly difficult problem. Even though this business model has only recently come into being, the corporations practicing it have become dominant, and the technologies and services are threaded throughout our lives, communities, and economies. Regulation will be a key element of a response. However, regulation should not simply be a reaction to technology and an attempt to curb its worst excesses: technology should not be taken as a fixed, external force that will inevitably follow a particular path. Nor is surveillance capitalism at its root a technological problem amenable to a purely technological fix. Instead, regulation and technology should be co-designed and co-evolved. Citizens and civil society organizations will play key roles as well, by pushing for more effective regulation and supporting technologies, by helping to foster alternative models for providing needed services, and by adopting new social practice.

Regulation and law

Regulation and law form key elements of possible solutions. We suggest four principal goals for regulation: protecting privacy, erecting barriers to behavior manipulation, protecting free speech and civic participation, and (probably most controversially) undermining the economic basis of the surveillance capitalism business model so that alternatives can take root and flourish. Having such alternatives should lessen the dependence on these IT companies, while still having a way that people and society can have access to useful IT services – and beyond this, support positive visions of the role of IT in communities and society.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.