Informed consent and the minimum data approach protect our personal information while browsing – this limits the damage of surveillance capitalism
Landwehr, Borning & Wulf 21 – [Marvin Landwehr is a Ph.D. student for Pluralist Economics and Socio-Informatics at the University of Siegen, Alan Borning is a Professor Emeritus in the Paul G Allen School of Computer Science & Engineering at the University of Washington, Volker Wulf is a professor in Information Systems and the director of the Media Research Institute at the University of Siegen; 12/19/21; “Problems with surveillance capitalism and possible alternatives for IT infrastructure”; https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/1369118X.2021.2014548?src=recsys; accessed 7/19/22; Lowell-JL]
Another area of legislative activity is do-not-track legislation. The general goal of these bills is to allow users to decide whether or not they are willing to be tracked by third-party websites while browsing websites and potentially while using other internet-based services.
True informed consent
One reaction to privacy concerns is to implement much stronger requirements for informed consent, of which the GDPR is one important example. Improving information and consent is certainly a good thing, but in our view is inadequate. Being deluged with pages and pages of consent agreements about what information is being gathered about you isn't that useful, and if the alternatives are to check the ‘agree’ box, or to be left out of a great deal of social and political interaction, this is not a particularly meaningful choice. However, stronger implementations of consent are possible.
As a thought experiment, suppose that surveillance capitalist corporations were required to operate under the same conditions that govern research involving human subjects. For example, in response to past abuses, the US government adopted the Belmont Report (1978), which laid out principles for human subjects research. It requires true informed consent, which must be voluntary and ongoing. That implies that the consent form must be straightforward and comprehensible – so no 30 page legal monstrosity as with typical corporate privacy statements – and the subject must be able to withdraw from the experiment at any time. Further, only data needed to conduct the study should be gathered, and must be deleted once the study is over and analysis is complete. The data must also be held confidential and protected – it would be forbidden, for example, to hand it over to another research group without consent.
If similar requirements were placed on surveillance capitalist firms, they would require true informed consent, the ability to withdraw ones data at any time, and would not allow the data to be shared without permission with a third party. People should be able to challenge inaccurate information and have it removed. Note that today people do not even have access to a transparent overview of how their private data is trapped, transferred, sold and aggregated. Therefore, as a prerequisite, these data pathways need to be visible for the user and the public regulators.
Further, in analogy with the human research requirements, only the data needed to provide the service in question could be gathered, but not the cloud of additional data that is gathered and retained as at present. In other words, what we advocate includes (but is not limited to) the concept of ‘minimum data.’ These corporations should not be allowed to collect data that is not necessary to provide their service. However, minimum data alone could still leave loopholes for service providers, e.g., they could claim all personal data collected is necessary for AI-powered algorithms to provide a service optimized to personal needs. Therefore, true informed consent in analogy with human research requirements exceeds the minimum data approach. Finally, the requirements should be much stronger for children and vulnerable populations (e.g., prisoners). For example, in many cases the companies should simply not be allowed to accumulate information on children.