Cyber-weapons are the only usable ASATs---U.S. dependence on satellite infrastructure incentivizes attacks that risk nuclear war
Abhijeet Singh Baghel 19, M.S. in Cybersecurity, Utica College, December 2019, “Cyber Warfare in Outer Space,” ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, document ID: 27670535
A future war in space includes the possibility of one or more anti-satellite (ASAT) attacks which could destroy one or several important satellites and quickly escalate to a nuclear conflict. In 2014, the Obama administration initiated the need to develop new ASAT defense strategies and technology to counter China after its second ASAT test the year before (Kulacki, 2016). Attacking any U.S. intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) satellite, Global Positioning System (GPS) or communication satellites using missiles such as long-range missiles or Co-Orbital ASATS is expensive, time-consuming, and is hard to keep a secret (Hitchens, 2019d & Wright, 2012). It could be used to deter initial U.S. involvement in conflict but would have devastating impacts on its loss (Please see Appendix A & B for more information).
It is no secret that the U.S.’s major vulnerabilities lie with modernizing the National Airspace System (NAS) and using only one source for timing, navigation, and communication (aka GPS) whereas Russia, Europe, China, and others utilize additional forms of satellite navigation systems (Livingstone & Lewis, 2016). Therefore, only the U.S. would suffer losses with the disruption or destruction of the GPS constellation. To achieve enough damage to the GPS constellation and other space-based assets would require several satellites to be disabled to successfully disrupt the network and disable the U.S. This would have to be done in quick succession before the U.S. could retaliate which is also hard to do and the adversary would have to covertly launch its missiles from several locations or maneuver ASATs currently in orbit to attack its targets. On the other hand, hostile cyber operations are a much bigger threat to the operation of satellites such as GPS (Findler, 2019). As both cyberspace and space assets increasingly rely on each other it is imperative to implement flexible, proactive cybersecurity measures as new threat actors, companies, and technologies are always expanding and evolving space activities (Findler, 2019).
Space and cyberspace share several similarities. Both, along with international waters and airspace, are a global common[s] for the international competition which in turn determines the global distribution of power (Heftye, 2017). Both have applications that affect the everyday lives of many people and economies worldwide (Asbek, 2014). Although cyberspace is a man-made domain, it produces virtual results used for military operations and, along with space, provides adversaries a viable platform for exploitation.
In the last decade the integration of internet-based infrastructure into space systems, such as communications satellites has become an integral part of how satellites operate (Mather, 2018). Along with ASATS, other technologies are being developed to “deny, degrade, deceive, disrupt, or destroy space assets,” thus rendering space infrastructure useless (DOD & DNI, 2011). This includes lasers capable of blinding and knocking down space assets, jamming signals from space, and cyberattacks on satellites which are often considered electronic attacks that are reversable in comparison to orbital threats or nuclear explosions which are irreversible as shown in Figure 1 (Harrison, Johnson, & Roberts, 2019).
The major difference between physical weapons and cyber-attacks is the cost and time associated with an attack. Space assets are vulnerable to cyber threats and the growing dependence on them for commercial and military purposes alike could pose a serious national security threat. There was a time that critical infrastructure was supported by its proprietary technologies of which many have been replaced with internet-based technologies. As a result, nearly anything can be attacked through the internet, especially the interconnected space-assets which will inevitably be a primary target in the case of significant conflict.