NATO unity is key – interoperability in space enables effective communication
Beyza Unal 19, PhD Old Dominion University, senior research fellow with the International Security Department at Chatham House, specializes in nuclear and cyber policies, worked in the Strategic Analysis Branch at NATO Allied Command and Transformation, William J. Fulbright alumna, July 2019, “Cybersecurity of NATO’s Space-based Strategic Assets,” https://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/default/files/2019-06-27-Space-Cybersecurity-2.pdf
Interoperability enables allies to operate their space systems without having to make adaptations so that their systems can function efficiently.
Interoperability has been an issue in the land, air, and maritime domains. Space-assets planning would benefit from the lessons learned in those domains – for instance, by studying and understanding the complexities involved in intelligence- and information-sharing across all domains. Allies could allocate funds towards a body of work that could focus on interoperability in space. Doctrines and standardization could help to improve interoperability among allied systems. Yet, allies should also realize that standardization would mean using the same vectors as a baseline, thus leading to an increase in risk (in the remaining vulnerabilities) across the alliance as a whole.
Allies should realize that standardization would mean using the same vectors as a baseline, thus leading to an increase in risk across the alliance as a whole.
In order to share secure information through SATCOM units, France, Germany, Norway and the US have formed the multilateral Coalition Network for Secure Information Sharing (CoNSIS). Through secure communications systems, CoNSIS’s objective is to enable better and more accurate decision-making, within a shorter period of time.71 In order to ease interoperability, CoNSIS uses commercial standards as its baseline.72 For future applications, it is advisable to check whether commercial standards meet cybersecurity demands for military requirements.
Interoperability in technology is desirable but remains a challenging construct. It could become the role of NATO to make national space services interoperable. Creating a catalogue of national services might be a good starting point. Interoperability could also be established at the product level (for example, in the field of space weather information) where the products are standardized across the alliance. In order to incentivize nations to invest in this endeavour, it might be helpful to calculate the cost of inadequate interoperability across the alliance to demonstrate current or potential monetary losses.