Only revitalizing NATO cooperation can stop a Sinocentric world order---failure to mobilize various geographic focuses allows numerous cyberspace threats.
Liselotte Odgaard 22, professor at the Norwegian Institute for Defense Studies, 2/24/2022, "NATO’s China Role: Defending Cyber and Outer Space," Washington Quarterly, 45(1), pp 175-180, https://doi.org/10.1080/0163660X.2022.2059145, sg
Rather than highlighting the need for a division of labor within NATO, the 2022 invasion has highlighted that Russia’s appetite for threatening Europe with military action is closely entwined with its long-standing strategic cooperation with China. Intelligence reports that China told Russia in February 2022 not to invade Ukraine before the end of the Winter Olympics in Beijing testify to the closely orchestrated Chinese-Russian approach to the West.18 Moscow and Beijing are both strategic opponents of the US, a shared status that has spurred them to coordinate their separate geostrategic priorities in Europe and the Indo-Pacific, forging unison pushback against what they consider Western encroachments on their spheres of interest.19 The poorer than expected performance of the Russian armed forces in its 2022 war with Ukraine has pushed China to try to appear neutral. Nevertheless, China has joined Russia in opposing further enlargement of NATO, and in the Indo-Pacific, Russia has joined China in opposing Taiwanese independence.20 It would be wise for Europe and the US to plan for Sino-Russian geostrategic coordination to continue unless more clear evidence that China will abandon Russia is presented. One thing is certain: China will work with the partners that help it advance a Sinocentric international order based on authoritarian regimes. And to counter this development, Europe and the United States need to devise effective mechanisms for joint responses to Beijing as well as to Moscow.
A US-European division of labor is not likely to help NATO develop tools to defend itself against threats from China and Russia. The lack of electronic warfare in Russia’s war with Ukraine has revealed gaps between its concept of operations and the tactics of the Ukrainian military. As demonstrated in prior operations in Syria and the Donbas, Russia will adapt and learn in the short and long term. For example, Russia can be expected to improve its electromagnetic spectrum management in order to enhance its planning and management of forces on the battlefield. Meanwhile, China is watching the performance of the parties involved in the war with a view to update its cyber and space capabilities as well as strategic concepts. As a consequence, both Russian and Chinese threats will continue to increasingly emerge in the cyber and space domains. This calls for global and functional defenses rather than an exclusive geographical focus. It is more important than ever to design NATO for a future where threats toward transatlantic security are global and requires a unified response.