Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Russia has capability to destroy NATO satellites and GPS – already hacked Ukraine.

Ayres ’22 (Thomas Ayres, retired U.S. Army major general, former general counsel of the Department of the Air Force. “Russia’s war could spread to space; the U.S. should be prepared” 04/26/22 https://spacenews.com/op-ed-russias-war-could-spread-to-space-the-u-s-should-be-prepared/)

As background, recall that in November 2021, while amassing forces on Ukraine’s borders, Russia launched an ASAT satellite missile that destroyed one of its own satellites in orbit. It caused hazardous orbital debris and at the time seemed senseless. Russian authorities blathered and quibbled.

In hindsight, Russia’s demonstration of offensive space capabilities was on their pre-invasion checklist. This preparatory step to invading Ukraine sent a dual warning. First, when Russia invades, don’t interfere with Russian space systems upon which the Russian military relies. Second, if you seek to come to Ukraine’s aid, U.S. and NATO satellites upon which you rely will be in jeopardy.

Even earlier, Russia has been saber rattling in space. In February 2020, Gen. John “Jay” Raymond, the chief of space operations of the U.S. Space Force, reported that a Russian inspector satellite had actively maneuvered near a U.S. national security satellite. The inspector satellite, as if from a Russian nesting doll, detached from another satellite to purposefully approach and threaten the U.S. satellite.  

This precursor message was also exceptionally clear. The satellites on which the data for the blue dot on your phone, nearly every global financial transaction, and the effectiveness of military forces relies, are not beyond Russian reach. 

Russia’s provocations in space continue even while we cooperate on the International Space Station (ISS). But the invasion has changed that calculus as well. Upon the announcement of U.S. sanctions on the aerospace industry, the director of Roscosmos, the Russian Space Agency, tweeted, “If you block cooperation with us, who will save the International Space Stations (ISS) from an uncontrolled de-orbit and fall into the United States or … Europe?” 

With American astronauts on board, purposeful sabotage of the ISS would certainly be an act of war. Looking for other avenues to voice displeasure, Roscosmos looked at the commercial space industry. They demanded the United Kingdom guarantee OneWeb’s satellites, which were to be launched on Russian Soyuz rockets, not be used for military purposes. The United Kingdom demurred and SpaceX rockets have come to OneWeb’s rescue. 

Rather than passively awaiting further signals of Russian power in space at a threshold below an act of war, the U.S. can and should take clear measures to deter Russian aggressive action in space, in addition to the recently announced self-imposed ASAT ban.  Failing to do so only invites Russian attempts to harass, degrade or even mistakenly destroy U.S. satellites. 

First, the intelligence community should remain focused on attributing harmful or menacing Russian moves in space and reveal them. Just as the U.S. published Russia’s playbook on the ground prior to the invasion of Ukraine, the U.S. should reveal every dangerous or unprofessional movement of satellites near friendly satellites and thereby send our own signals to deter Russian malign activity in Space

Second, the Biden administration must forcefully pronounce a redline in space.  Even as SpaceX and Elon Musk helpfully delivered Starlink terminals, the U.S. must message that uninterrupted internet and satellite communications for U.S. and NATO forces and allies in eastern Europe is a national security asset. If our satellite network is attacked in any manner, it will be considered an act of war.  

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.