Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Russian and Chinese cyber operations against space-based capabilities can decimate NATO’s ability to [everything].

Dr. Beyza Unal 19, Former Deputy Director of the International Security Program, July 1 2019, “Cybersecurity of NATO’s Space-based Strategic Assets”, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2019/07/cybersecurity-natos-space-based-strategic-assets-0/2-cyber-risks-space-based-strategic **Altered for ableist language. We do not endorse any ableist language.

Considering that digital technologies are fundamental to all six of the space-dependent capabilities described above, none of them is immune to cyberattacks. Moreover, any digital system that relies upon near real-time information is vulnerable to cyberattacks. The loss of one or more of these capabilities because of human or system error or through offensive cyber operations conducted by an adversary, could have severe strategic, operational and tactical consequences. In order to understand the value of each space-dependent capability, it is important to analyse the consequences of cyberattacks on each.

Cyberattacks on military weapons systems may have operational and strategic consequences that change the way the military operates in conflict. Although electronic warfare has been in use for more than a century, sophisticated cyberattacks on the systems of NATO or its key member countries have a new and distinct impact on decision-making and on how NATO conducts its operations. Cyberattacks on military systems could also have a paralysing effect on strategic military and political decision-making and could render NATO countries vulnerable to Russian or Chinese information and deception operations.

Timing is a crucial element of PNT capability. Most of the electronics used in military, civilian and commercial spheres depend on timing signals. By intercepting securely transmitted data through cyber means, an adversary may jeopardize the alliance’s missions and services. A compromised system would also diminish reliance on data received, as data confidentiality would be brought into question through possible acts of spoofing and deception.

The involvement of Russia and the US in the Syrian conflict, and the use of electronic techniques, such as signal jamming, and cyber means, such as hacking and spoofing, demonstrates the potential operational uses of cyberattacks. Russia’s electronic warfare capability involves not only an air defence capability but also integrates cyber operations.58

What type of consequences would result from cyberattacks within space-based systems? What would be the operational and strategic impact? The table below outlines some of the potential consequences for each capability:

Table 2: NATO space-dependent capabilities and potential consequences from their absence NATO space-dependent capabilities Potential impact from the loss of capabilities Position, navigation and timing (PNT) • Impacts on the civilian airspace, such as airliners losing on-board navigation systems (which is not directly within NATO’s purview, but which would affect the scale of the conflict or crisis in general. Moreover, an attack on civil systems could result in military consequences). • Losing contact with the alliance’s forces and assets during their deployment. • Loss of the time signal and its impact on the functioning of warships and guided missiles. • Losing connection with ships, aircraft, carriers etc. in conflict due to interference to their navigation systems. • Loss of precise time to create financial transaction timestamps as financial sector’s internal clocks rely on GPS. • Cyberattacks on the guidance mechanism of a weapon (such as a missile) that would result in failure of weapons delivery accuracy. • Impact on the security of mission-critical assets and mission assurance.59 Intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR) • Interference to the ISR capability that leads to faulty assessment and response to threats. • NATO could lose the possibility to transmit ISR information over potential adversaries’ territory. • Loss of situational awareness in peacetime and at times of conflict, resulting in faulty decision-making. • Loss of battlefield awareness for the commander, thus putting the desired operational objective in danger. • Manipulation of ISR data through spoofing attacks, which could cripple defensive systems by sending falsified or excess information to decision-makers. Missile defence • The loss of missile defence capabilities in peacetime due to cyberattacks would diminish situational awareness on ballistic missile launches in the world – reducing intelligence on when and where a missile is launched, and by whom. In times of conflict and warfare, losing this capability may result in unintentional escalation. • In times of conflict, such a loss will have strategic, operational and tactical consequences for NATO missions and operations. • Cyberattacks on missile defence could occur in the form of spoofing, thus deceiving the ballistic missile command system. • The inadequate interception of the upcoming ballistic missile may result with civilian casualties. Communications • Losing communication systems or receiving spoofed data, thus compromising the integrity of information received. • Decision-makers (including presidents, prime ministers and senior military cadres) may not be able to send the necessary orders down the chain of command. • Decisions based on faulty information may lead to escalation and decrease the threshold for conflict. Space situational awareness • Loss of control or destruction of satellite control systems through the targeting of those systems or of mission packages by cyberattacks. • Altering the orbit of the satellite or ‘grilling’ its solar cells by exposing it to high levels of ionizing radiation.60 • Inability to detect, predict or assess space debris or its re-entry, which could impact on life. • Disruption of missions and all other space services, thus impacting on military operations and on human life. Environmental monitoring • Cyberattacks on weather systems or on environmental monitoring systems may cause problems in defence planning for an attack as the military rely on daily weather information to conduct its operations. • Weather information is fundamental for land, air, and maritime domains. Cyberattacks on weather forecasting systems could impact on operational capacity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.