Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Existential war with China or Russia is a real threat – especially if China can conduct cyberattacks on US satellites.

Dean, ’19 (Eric Dean, Future Readiness Officer at the Office of the Chief of Chaplains, US Army. “Can the United States Wage Existential Warfare Without Foundational Principles or Truths?” 03/25/19 https://www.cgscfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/5-Dean-Existential-Warfare.pdf)

For many Americans, the idea of waging existential warfare is the stuff of dystopian films. In the years following the Second World War, the United States emerged as one of two global superpowers whose ability to exercise its influence and will was challenged only by the Soviet Union. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, however, the U.S. has maintained global superiority—or dominance—in every domain of warfare, enjoying a unique status as the world’s only superpower. Over the past three decades, the military prowess of the United States has been largely without peer, thus the notion of existential warfare is inconceivable for many Americans. Further adding to this collective American naiveté is the fact that the last time the United States fought foreign forces on American soil was during the War of 1812, a time so far removed from the American conscience that it is difficult to imagine. Though the United States has suffered isolated attacks since then at Pearl Harbor and again on 9/11, the U.S. always has taken the fight to its enemies in their homelands, sparing our own the destruction and suffering war inevitably brings. Consequently, the possibility of waging a truly existential war is difficult at best for the average American to consider. The reality however is that if war were to break out tonight between the United States and an alliance of SinoRussian forces, the U.S. likely would lose. In simulated wargames conducted by the RAND Corporation, the U.S. continues to lose catastrophically against Russia and China as its bases, warships, and aircraft are decimated.1 RAND analyst, David Ochmanek, confirms that there is no situation under current conditions in which the United States emerges victorious in a war with Russia and China.2 With Russia touting hypersonic, precision-guided intercontinental ballistic missiles, the repercussions of consolidating personnel and equipment under Base Realignment and Closure, as well as staging large numbers of personnel and aircraft on a few large airbases and aircraft carriers translates to catastrophic loss of life and strategic assets within minutes for United States forces.3 China poses an equally devastating threat to communication networks, effectively employing a superior cyber and electronic warfare campaign against U.S. satellites, network, and communication systems.4 According to Robert Work, a former deputy secretary of defense and wargaming expert, the U.S has wargamed cyber and electronic warfare in field exercises, but “the simulated enemy forces tend to shut down United States networks so effectively that nothing works and nobody else gets any training done.”5 Assuming U.S forces somehow were able to organize and wage land warfare after these initial devastating assaults, United States ground forces would not fare much better. According to another recent RAND study, both Russian and Chinese rocket systems match or outrange current U.S. capabilities.6 Similarly, Russian field artillery outranges anything currently within the U.S. arsenal.7 Thus the reality is that should the U.S. to go to war today against a Sino-Russian force, our current forward-deployed and expeditionary-focused military forces would be destroyed or severely damaged, resulting in the Nation suddenly finding itself in it what would be an existential war conducted under large-scale combat operation conditions.8 In addition to the strategic and tactical disadvantages facing the U.S., the very nature of large-scale combat operations in a multi-domain environment where battles will be brutally fought in mega-cities creates a significant moral dilemma for American political and military leaders. The expected catastrophic loss of civilian and military lives undoubtedly will result in enormous public pressure to develop weapons and tactics to quickly end such a conflict, positing that the achieved victory will justify the means.9

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.