Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cyberthreats can decimate NATO’s functioning in all areas of operation---overreliance and lack of protection.

Dr. Beyza Unal 19, Former Deputy Director of the International Security Program, July 1 2019, “Cybersecurity of NATO’s Space-based Strategic Assets”, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2019/07/cybersecurity-natos-space-based-strategic-assets-0/2-cyber-risks-space-based-strategic \\SYang

Space systems, which include both satellites and ground stations, as well as related space products and services, provide mission-critical information both for NATO’s member states and for the alliance as a whole. NATO relies on space-based assets for almost all of its operations and missions.29 Some of the critical missions that rely on space assets include: defence of NATO’s territory and the neighbouring regions; peacekeeping missions; humanitarian assistance and disaster relief; counterterrorism; and conflict prevention activities.

NATO does not own satellites. It owns and operates a few terrestrial elements, such as satellite communications (SATCOM) anchor stations and terminals. It requests access to products and services but does not have direct access to satellites, leaving it up to its allies to determine whether they provide access to their satellite capabilities. NATO has established memoranda of understanding with allies for possible use of space products and services.

Originally, in the US, space systems used by the military were separated from commercial and civilian assets in terms of their development and operation.30 One of the reasons for this separation was to protect the military structure against physical and cyberthreats. Military space system safety and security requirements were also higher and more stringent than in the commercial sphere (for example, requirements to invest in survivability enhancement mechanisms in order to resist jamming, or special design approaches for military space architecture). In recent years commercial methods, for instance the capture and analysis of satellite imagery, have been shown to be as effective as military means. As a result, NATO uses a mix of military, civilian, commercial, and national/multinational assets to conduct its operations. The joint use of these assets, however, comes with an acceptance of inherent risk, not only to the countries that provide such capability but also to the alliance as a whole. In response, the European Defence Agency, through its Governmental Satellite Communications (GOVSATCOM) development programme, decided to build an intermediary class of satellites between commercial SATCOM and military SATCOM, with security requirements able to address the needs of critical missions, including crisis management.31

There is increased dependence on space-based systems in modern military engagement. During the US engagement in Iraq in 2003, 68 per cent of munitions were guided utilizing space-based means (including laser-, infrared- and satellite-guided munitions); this percentage had risen sharply from 10 per cent in 1990–91, during the first Gulf war.32 In its operations in Afghanistan in 2001, 60 per cent of the weapons used by the US were precision-guided munitions: these included bombs, missiles, and other weapons, many of which had the capability to correct their own positioning to hit the target, using space-derived information.33

This dependency on space-based technology has major implications for the way NATO conducts warfare today, and how it will do so in the future. For instance, in order to conduct precision strikes or earth observation through the use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs – such as military drones), systems rely on so-called ‘beyond-line-of-sight’ (BLOS) communication via satellites – especially in times of crisis and conflict, since ground-based line-of-sight communications are vulnerable to physical attacks. Yet, cyberattacks on space technology or on the UAVs may lead them to misinterpret commands, or to lose contact with the command centre and fail in operation.

NATO currently uses six space-dependent capabilities for its alliance operations and missions:

Position, navigation and timing (PNT)

Intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR)

Missile defence

Communications

Space situational awareness (SSA)

Environmental monitoring (weather forecasting)

The core functioning of these six capabilities for NATO operations includes:

Providing communication in military operations and missions, for instance between a commander and their troops;

Providing early warning, through detecting the hot plumes of a ballistic missile launch – thus, increasing the time available to respond to an upcoming threat;

Providing a precise location for targeted strikes;34

Providing imagery of targets, in order to observe, detect and analyse their status (situational awareness);

Providing GPS for weapon guidance;

Providing timing for secure communications; and

Providing space surveillance and tracking.

The table below outlines the key roles for each capability:

<<<TABLE 1 OMITTED>>>

Identification is another important capability that is used in the NATO maritime domain for coastal tracking, and for identifying and locating ships and vessels. Using automatic identification systems (AIS), data is electronically transmitted between ships and the coastal stations. By providing similar functions, AIS supplements and provides resilience to maritime radar and is fundamental for avoiding collisions.36

NATO’s space-dependent capabilities have individual functions, as described above. These capabilities are also coupled to each other, with complex cross-dependencies, so that the loss of one capability may have a collateral impact on other capabilities. For instance, most of the assets that transmit communications to support command and control are also dependent on GPS for timing and synchronization.37 Although there would be a number of contenders for technologies of utmost importance to NATO missions and operations, preliminary research indicates that PNT signals (which utilize GPS) are a much-needed priority capability in almost all NATO operations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.