Allied governance is uniquely effective in space---the counterplan forces a purely national model that forfeits integration, cost-sharing, and legitimacy
-National action can’t solve questions of international legitimacy, protecting the environment, and joint operations. CP key to beat out Russia and China
James Clay Moltz 11, professor in the National Security Affairs Department at the Naval Postgraduate School, October 2011, “Coalition Building in Space: Where Networks are Power,”
The issue of spacecraft vulnerability relates to certain basic facts of orbital physics combined with the relative transparency of space to radar, optical, and infrared observation. 6 These conditions make spacecraft liable to tracking by even amateur astronomers with only moderately sophisticated equipment, which is easily obtainable by any entry-level space power. While more complex guidance technology is required for actual attacks on space assets and a global network of radars is needed for conducting post-attack assessments of damage done, the ability of even moderately advanced space powers to conduct significant counterspace activities is not in question. Thus far, only Russia, the United States, and China have tested kinetic capabilities, but a number of other countries (including Iran) have carried out lesser forms of electronic interference. As a major space assessment conducted by NATO's Joint Air Power Competence Centre in 2009 reported on some of the current vulnerabilities faced by the alliance in space:
There are real and credible threats to Space systems. The ground systems are vulnerable to attack. There has been demonstrated use of GPS and SATCOM jammers. Anti-satellite (ASAT) weapons have been demonstrated by the Soviet Union ... and in January of 2007, China demonstrated its capability [ ... ]. The potential exists for ground-based laser weapons, electro-magnetic pulse, and co-orbital ASAT weapons. Additionally, there are risks of collision from Space debris and impacts from solar events. There have been many instances of satellite telecommunications interference and piracy.7
Space assets are also threatened by a field of orbital space debris that is steadily growing due to the increase in human space activity and the inability of space to "clean" itself quickly. Depending on the altitude of the orbit, it can take years, decades, or centuries for pieces of space debris to deorbit. In the meantime, these particles (even as small as 1 centimeter) represent 18,000 miles-per-hour speeding bullets, which can destroy solar cells and cause often fatal damage to any spacecraft that are unfortunate enough to cross their paths.8 Today's space environment is also characterized by an expansion in the number of civil, commercial, and military space actors, making international agreements more difficult than in the past.
In the face of these risks and evidence of both expanding military space programs and weapons test programs in several countries, the response by many U.S. military leaders, elected officials, and even experts is still a traditional call for exclusively national action to "defend" U.S. assets in space. To take just one U.S. example, Senator Jon Kyl (Rep., Arizona) stated after the 2007 Chinese ASAT test that the United States must deploy a fleet of space-based weapons to defend itself in space.9 He made no mention of the threat China posed to other allied nations or their possible contributions to the U.S. response.
Historical conditions of anarchy in the international system have contributed to a tendency among leaders to conceive mainly of national responses to international threats. States are already organized for national defense, countries are jealous of spending scarce resources in potentially risky ventures with foreigners (even allies), and there are relatively low levels of trust regarding the reliability of international organizations. But three factors have altered global dynamics in the last few decades, each of which has an important space component that supports the creation of an allied approach to space.
First, the scale of multinational interactions to deal with shared problems is increasing due to the growing "finiteness" of the globe, as the world's population continues to expand and as communications technologies become more intrusive and more widespread. Indeed, the very nature of the problems countries are facing is changing as the Earth becomes "smaller": almost all free land and airspace (up to 100 kilometers) have been claimed by nations (or otherwise allotted by international law), the sheer scale of industrial pollutants is beginning to have global effects, and such resources as clean air and water are becoming increasingly scarce. Other problems, such as climate change, are becoming recognized as requiring an international response. Despite its comparative vastness, near-Earth space faces some of the same risks of growing human activity, particularly due to the finiteness of its main, usable resources (geo-stationary orbital slots, radio frequencies available for broadcasting, and safe access to low-Earth orbit). All of these resources are becoming stressed by increasing human space activity.
Second, and related, economic globalization is an increasing fact of life. Unlike during the Cold War, when the world was dominated by two, nearly self-sufficient blocs, changes in the international economic system (due to both political and technological factors) has made commercial exchange possible across almost all political boundaries, vastly increasing global trade. Interdependent economic relationships are the rule in U.S. ties with our NATO and Asian allies and even, in some areas, with commercial partners like Russia and China. Similar to many industries, the commercial space industry has become truly international and now generates $161-billion in sales, 10 making it a valuable resource for both national governments and the global economy more generally. Technologies built in one country are frequently owned and marketed by another and are sold to clients in yet another. Strong corporate alliances have already been formed in the space industry, for example, linking Russian rocket motors with U.S. launch vehicles (International Launch Services) and U.S. sub-orbital flight technology with British funding and marketing (Virgin Galactic). With some offshore corporations like Intelsat, it is often diflicult to tell which individual country a space enterprise actually "belongs" to. National militaries are also purchasing bandwidth on a large number of commercial satellites, causing the breadth of a country's "critical assets" to expand. Some of these assets are already shared with other nations, although not in a joint operational sense. Yet devoted military space cooperation between countries remains highly restricted and out of step with these integrationist tends.
Third, in military affairs, questions of international legitimacy are placing a growing emphasis on the need to conduct operations via coalitions. Put simply, the unilateral use of force is seen as increasingly unacceptable within the international community. Largely for this reason, the United States fought under a U.N. mandate in 1991 in the Gulf War against Iraq's intervention into Kuwait and in Libya in 2011; it fought under a NATO mandate in the Balkans and now in Afghanistan; and it fought (less "legitimately" from the perspective of the rest of the world) with an ad hoc coalition of friends and allies in 2003 in Iraq. Indeed, there is a growing literature on the need for some international approval even for humanitarian interventions by military forces in the modern era.11 Ironically, given these pressures to cooperate in military activity, space remains an outlier. Unfortunately, the U.S. military has found by experience in Afghanistan that national barriers have impeded its effective use of space-derived data. As a one recent analysis of the problem of information-sharing in Afghanistan observes: "secrecy often keeps coalition team members from speaking about space-related topics with each other."12
But these points raise a critical "process" question: How do countries come to realize that their security needs in an area of activity have crossed the line from national to international? Realist political theory argues that security, by its very nature, is something that falls to states, as the essential building blocks of the international system and the repositories of sovereignty within it. Yet space is an area specifically delineated as beyond national sovereignty by international law in the 1967 Outer Space Treaty. The failure of states to expand collective governance mechanisms more in regard to space may be a factor of habit, perspective, and inertia, plus normal bureaucratic opposition to negotiations aimed at creating new, specialized institutions beyond national control.
Recent threats to U.S. space assets have been viewed as national security threats because there is a long U.S. tradition of self-reliance in international relations and a perspective that successful collective action is rarely achieved. But, in space, all countries have an interest in protecting the environment from military threats and, in fact, from any obstacles to either free access or free passage. These conditions create fundamental incentives for collective action that do not exist in other areas of international relations. Ironically, one of the primary obstacles to enhanced collective action to protect space security may be the thinking of the actors themselves, which still remains largely rooted in the unilateral traditions of security provision from past security frameworks. But, as Robert Keohane argues, "To pursue self-interest does not require maximizing freedom of action. On the contrary, intelligent and farsighted leaders understand that attainment of their objectives may depend on their commitment to institutions that make cooperation possible."13 Working with allies, therefore, may represent the best security solution available at this point in space history, and perhaps may serve as a bridge to broader forms of international cooperation in the future. Alliance-based efforts could mitigate a variety of emerging space-related security concerns. The prior existence of allied military institutions- particularly established patterns of cost-sharing, integration, joint operations, and joint training- both in the case of NATO and in various bilateral arrangements with Asian countries (such as Australia, Japan, and South Korea) should reduce typical collective action problems in forming such new mechanisms for space.