Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turf wars deck solvency

Bender 16 (Bryan Bender, B.A in Political Science and English @ University of Pittsburg, Adjunct ProfessorAdjunct Professor Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, Senior National CorrespondentSenior National Correspondent POLITICO .“Pentagon muscles out State Dept. on foreign aid” https://www.politico.com/story/2016/03/general-diplomats-tussle-over-pentagons-growing-military-aid-portfolio-221177)LR

“During the course of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars in particular — and then more recently related to Iraq and Syria — there has been this steady accumulation of very specific authorities that have largely gone over to the Department of Defense,” the former Air Force officer and special assistant to the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff said in an interview. But now that large-scale combat in Iraq and Afghanistan has diminished, “It’s a fair question to ask, ‘Do we have the balance right between State and DoD?’” For decades, the power largely rested with the State Department, which is responsible for setting and implementing foreign policy. It has traditionally played the lead role in deciding who should get U.S. security assistance and has asserted its authority to squelch military proposals it considers unwise, officials said. Last year, the department vetoed a Pentagon plan to train snipers from Belarus, which has no free elections and where political dissidents continue to disappear with no government explanation. State also recently scuttled a plan to provide lip balm and brooms to the Jordanian military — items the department deemed wasteful. The Defense Department, though, increasingly has dollars on its side. The Pentagon’s budget for such overseas military aid has more than tripled from 2008 to 2015, compared with just 23 percent growth for the State Department, according to internal administration data provided to POLITICO. “You are going to see disagreement any time DoD is proposing a change of program in a way that the State Department would perceive as diminishing the degree of coordination that is required,” said a senior administration official directly involved in the internal deliberations. Even without a change in the law, though, the State Department has found itself virtually shut out of the review process in some cases, according to interviews with current and former department officials. For example, the diplomats recently learned the Pentagon was funding counter-narcotics operations in several nations in Central Asia that the State Department had previously deemed ineligible for military assistance. State also learned from media reports that the Pentagon was training a controversial Cambodian army general. And despite efforts to better coordinate the two departments’ activities, confusion remains about who is doing what. One consequence: The Pentagon has a program underway to provide $100 million worth of new helicopters to the Kenyan military, while State has separately pursued efforts to supply it with used helicopters. The State Department isn’t concerned solely about human rights and the aid recipients’ international behavior. Its supporters also argue that the State Department is better positioned than the military to manage the programs long-term. “There is no sustainment process with DoD,” said another administration official involved in the policy debate. “Ships we have provided are rusting pierside.” A recent analysis by the Congressional Research Service also concluded that recent policy decisions “have combined to slowly muddle the clear legal separation between State and DoD roles.” A March 9 analysis by the government-funded Rand Corp. similarly called for reviewing the two departments’ “roles, interests and coordination processes.” “This trend of giving more and more authority and taking them away from State is not a great thing,” said Ilan Goldenberg, who runs the Middle East Security Program at the Center for a New American Security. “It is largely a function that in Congress DoD gets a lot more attention and has a lot more leverage.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.