Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Recipient countries fail to understand the complexity of US bureaucracy

Arnold 20, colonel in USAF (Jason, “Add Value to Security Cooperation through Joint Unification,” FAO Journal of International Affairs, https://faoajournal.substack.com/p/add-value-to-security-cooperation?s=r)

In the Security Cooperation Enterprise, the military departments loom large as the primary implementing agencies of Foreign Military Sales (FMS) cases, Building Partner Capacity (BPC) cases, and in training activities.[6] These SC programs provide our international partners with the capabilities they require both for their own security and to assist in regional security objectives that improve the overall global security situation. Most open SC cases have one of the military departments as an Implementing Agency (IA) and each service has built its own organizational structure, bureaucracy, and automated systems to support the effort.[7] Over the decades, a familiar dynamic has taken place. The military departments have developed their own implementing processes in an insular way, isolated from the other branches, and accommodating their own unique business rules, methods, and systems separate from the others. In addition to contributing to the already significant complexity of the SC Enterprise, the familiar replication of effort, divergent doctrine and practice, and inefficient use of resources is again evident. Still, the Services continue to diverge. Consider the difficulties these differing systems place on our international partners. Friendly foreign nations, committed to working toward our mutual security interests, must not only understand the various roles and processes in the general realm of SC, but also must learn the complexities of several different systems, depending on the implementing agency for a particular program. Indeed, this complexity is one of the primary complaints of the SC processes from our partners. Perhaps the complexity would be justified if it added value, but in almost all cases, the different processes add no greater benefit, but are due simply to the fact that they were developed in isolation by different organizations. Integrated processes and systems that are standardized across the implementing agencies would be a vast improvement, providing increased transparency, reduced complexity, and greater effectiveness across the board. Security Cooperation is inherently an interagency process, and requires a whole of government effort. Presidential Policy Directive 23 identified the Department of State (DoS) as the lead agency for United States Security Sector Assistance Policy, and all Security Assistance and Security Cooperation efforts require coordination and consent across agencies. The interagency process can be hampered by the diversity of processes and players that are presented by the separate Services’ SC organizations. It is not only our international partners that struggle with learning the different ways and means of the various implementing agencies, our own interagency partners can experience confusion as well in navigating the various systems, doctrine, and processes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.