Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Democratic backsliding ensures political divisions wrecking NATO cohesion

Flockhart 2021

Trine Flockhart is Professor of International Relations in the Department of Political Science and Public Management at the University of Southern Denmark and Co-Director of the Center for War Studies. Trine’s research focuses on international order and processes of change and transformation, the crisis in the liberal international order, resilience and NATO and transatlantic relations. “Democratic Backsliding and Contested Values Within the Alliance,” NATO 2030: Towards a New Strategic Concept and Beyond, (177-194), 2021.dmr

The authors of the 2030 report are correct in emphasizing the importance of NATO’s commitment to shared values, but it must also be recognized that in the current political environment, agreement about those values can no longer be taken for granted—this is the case both within the Alliance, but it is also a wider problem reflecting that there is now a broadly shared consensus that the basic norms underpinning the overall liberal international order are under pressure and that global politics will be shaped by open disagreements about its basic values.8 The very same challenging international security environment that makes the commitment essential has also stirred political sentiments within the Alliance that may make it difficult—perhaps even impossible—for the Alliance to live up to the commitment. Democracy today is in crisis and NATO’s foundational values are contested in several member states such as Hungary, Turkey, and even Poland. In these member states, the possibility of democratic backsliding is today no longer unthinkable—it is already taking place.9 Even some of the oldest democracies—the United States, Britain, and France—face diminishing confidence in their democratic institutions and significant disruptions in their domestic politics. The rise of right-wing, authoritarian-style populism and an apparent mainstreaming of national(ist) politics is no longer just an abstract threat but a reality that is currently in the process of altering long established cleavage structures in party politics.11 These changes seem likely to result in new political divisions within the Alliance between liberal internationalism and illiberal nationalism. Clearly such a situation will have profound ramifications for cohesion within the Alliance and for the continued shared commitment to NATO’s foundational values. This chapter asks if the Alliance can continue to live up to its commitment to “democracy, individual liberty and rule of law” and asks how democratic backsliding may constitute an existential threat to NATO. The chapter consists of four sections. The first section outlines how NATO has historically been able to adapt to a frequently changing external strategic environment to meet a seemingly never-ending stream of crises—qualities that arguably made NATO a resilient institution. In the second section, the chapter attributes NATO’s resilience to the ability of the Alliance to balance between two different, but intertwined identities—an identity as a defense alliance and an identity as a community of values.12 The chapter demonstrates that historically, NATO’s crises, tensions, and contradictions have primarily been associated with the identity as a defense alliance, whereas the value foundation of the Alliance has been continuously reinforced and reified through deeply embedded practices associated with NATO’s identity as a community of values. In the third section, the chapter shows that today, the situation has changed fundamentally as the Alliance is doing well in areas that have historically caused the most concern such as its military capabilities, whereas NATO’s assumed bedrock of strength—its stable identity, deeply embedded practices, and shared values—is now contested from within its own ranks. In the final section, the chapter turns to contemplating NATO’s future and the prospects for NATO not only to return to long-established practices to reinforce the shared values of the Alliance, but also the prospects for the Alliance to reorient itself towards a very different and challenging strategic environment.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.