Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hungary will not change course, even with NATO pressure.

Deni ’20 — John; Ph.D., is a research professor of JIIM security studies at the Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army War College and the author of “NATO and Article 5.” April 30, 2020; "NATO punishment won’t make Hungary’s dictator change course"; TheHill; [edited for ableist language] https://thehill.com/opinion/international/494433- NATO-punishment-wont-make-hungarys-dictator-change-course/; //CYang

More tangibly, recently improved ties between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Orban’s government present other serious problems. At best, they weaken NATO’s united front toward Russia over its actions in Ukraine; at worst, they represent a potentially grave security risk.

The alliance’s reluctance to do much over Hungary stems from several factors. First, the NATO treaty has no provisions for sanctioning, punishing or expelling a member state. Individual member states may decide to withdraw from the alliance, but neither NATO nor any other country can force them to do so.

Second, NATO has a long history of turning a blind [ignorance] eye to democratic backsliding among its members. Greece was led by a military dictatorship from 1967-74, and Turkey experienced military-led coups in 1960 and 1980. And one of its founding members, Portugal, was a dictatorship until 1974. In each of these instances, geopolitical realities — namely, the Cold War struggle against the Soviet Union — trumped concerns over democratic values.

Even if the alliance treaty had provisions for punishing or expelling a member state, it’s very likely another member state would side with Hungary, frustrating consensus. Poland and Turkey come to mind, given their own struggles with democratic backsliding in recent years — and likely concern that they might be shown the exits next.

Some might add to this list Hungary’s important geographic attributes, sitting in the center of Europe, bordering Ukraine, and forming a land bridge from allies in the south to those in the north. Hungary isn’t a geopolitical lynchpin, however. It doesn’t compare in this regard to any of the Baltic States, which sit at the epicenter of strategic competition in Europe, or to Turkey, with its long Black Sea coastline, its borders with Iran, Iraq and Syria, and its control of the Bosporus Strait. And if NATO ever needed to quickly move forces by land between the Eastern Mediterranean and the Baltics, it could transit Ukraine, which never has been friendlier toward the West, or Austria, which also has become closer to NATO.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.