Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO say no because of inherent distrust in US data privacy law

Schwartz & Peifer 17 – Paul M. Schwartz is the Jefferson E. Peyser Professor of Law at the UC Berkeley School of Law and the Director of the Berkeley Center for Law & Technology. Karl-Nikolaus Peifer is a Professor of Law at the University of Cologne and the Director of the Institute for Media Law and Communications Law. (“Transatlantic Data Privacy Law,” Georgetown Law Journal vol. 106 issue 1, November 2017, https://www.law.georgetown.edu/georgetown-law-journal/wp-content/uploads/sites/26/2019/10/Transatlantic-Data-Privacy-Law_Schwartz-and-Peifer.pdf ) PJW

INTRODUCTION Due to the significance of international flows of personal information, the stakes are high today for the European Union (EU) and the United States when it comes to data privacy law. According to one estimate, the EU-U.S. economic relationship involves $260 billion in annual digital services trade.' Cross-border information flows represent the fastest growing component of trade in both the EU and the United States. As one technology reporter noted, "International data transfers are the lifeblood of the digital economy." 2 Yet, differences in transatlantic regulations potentially imperil critical international data flows. 3 In today's information economy, much of the EU-U.S. data trade involves personal data. Leading U.S. companies depend on access to and use of the personal information of EU citizens to provide data-driven services on the continent. Cloud providers, which offer decentralized mobile access to computing power throughout the world, similarly access and use the personal data of EU citizens. A threat to these data flows derives from EU doubts as to whether the United States has sufficient privacy protection. The resulting EU-U.S. dispute has been termed the "transatlantic data war." 4 This term refers to the transatlantic conflict around transfers of personal data. The roots of this "war" are found in the differing legal approaches to information privacy in the two jurisdictions. The differences are institutional, substantive, and, at the same time, elusive. Both sides recognize information privacy as an important value yet struggle to identify the meaning of core differences and the critical baseline for future collaboration. In the United States, there has been skepticism about EU privacy rights and whether they are merely disguised protectionism. 5 In the EU, there has been a longstanding debate about whether U.S. law provides sufficient protections for the personal information of EU citizens when U.S. companies and public authorities collect and process it.6 This policy debate has been accompanied by the EU setting strict limits on transfers of personal data to any non-EU country that lacks significant privacy protections. The restrictions are set by two EU legal mandates. The first is the European Directive on Data Protection, which permits data transfers from the EU to a thirdparty nation only when it has "adequate" privacy protections.7 The second is the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which will replace the Directive on May 25, 2018." Under the GDPR, the adequacy requirement for data transfers continues to be the legal touchstone.9 The EU has never considered U.S. data privacy law to have an adequate level of protection.o It has faulted U.S. information privacy law for its patchwork nature and lack of adequate remedies. In response to the EU's judgment that the privacy protections of U.S. law are insufficient, the EU and the United States developed a set of first-generation solutions for transatlantic exchanges. A turning point for these mechanisms came in June 2013, with the start of Edward Snowden's revelations regarding the practices of the National Security Agency (NSA)." For the EU, the resulting information demonstrated that the NSA had engaged in data surveillance of EU citizens without adequate respect for their data privacy rights. The NSA's storage and analysis of bulk data pertaining to EU citizens was a major point of contention. 12 The resulting political firestorm has either invalidated or imperiled all firstgeneration transatlantic data transfer mechanisms. 13 An initial second-generation solution, the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield, was finalized in June 2016.14 There are already legal challenges to it in the EU. 1 5 Bridging the transatlantic data divide is, therefore, a matter of the greatest significance. On the horizon is a possible international policy solution around "interoperable," or shared legal concepts. President Barack Obama and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) promoted this approach. For the Obama White House, there was a need for a "multistakeholder process" with the international partners of the United States to "facilitate interoperable privacy regimes." 1 6 These regimes were to be based on the starting point of "mutual recognition," which entailed an "embrace of common values surrounding privacy and personal data protection." 1 7 The extent of EU-U.S. data privacy interoperability, however, remains to be seen. In exploring this issue, this Article analyzes the respective legal identities constructed around data privacy in the EU and the United States. It identifies profound differences in the two systems' image of the individual as bearer of legal interests. The EU has created a privacy culture around "rights talk" that serves to protect "data subjects." 8 In the EU, rights talk forms a critical part of the postwar European project of creating the identity of a European citizen. As Jirgen Habermas argues, this task is a constitutional one that is central to the EU's survival.19 In the United States, by contrast, data privacy law is based on the idea of consumers whose interests merit governmental protection in a marketplace marked by deception and unfairness. In the United States, the focus is on "marketplace discourse" about personal information and the safeguarding of "privacy consumers. "20 This Article uses the models of rights talk and marketplace discourse to analyze how the EU and United States protect their respective data subjects and privacy consumers. A focus of the Article is on the respective doctrines of consent and contract in the two legal systems, which reflect profoundly different perspectives. In the EU, there is a collective approach to ordering privacy. Consequently, the EU limits contract through strict requirements of necessity, purpose limitation, and a ban on "tying." 21 As for consent, it is subject to limits in the EU that make it unusable in many areas as a legal basis for personal data processing. Where the focus of the EU is on restricting consent and contract, these doctrines are absent in U.S. data privacy law. In the absence of a requirement of a legal justification for personal data processing, parties in the United States can collect and use personal data without consent or contract.22 Their only duty is to follow any sector laws or other mandates that might exist. There are also likely future forces for convergence and divergence on the horizon. The forces moving the two legal systems for privacy together are a shared technological environment, increased political agreement around the benefits of personal data flow, and common security and law enforcement concerns. The forces moving the systems apart begin with the political and institutional dimensions of the EU's rights talk. There are also great differences concerning privacy remedies and a strong possibility for misunderstandings and disagreements around concepts of contract and consent in the two systems.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.