Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Norms fail to regulate biotech military application

Finabel ’21 — European Army Interoperability Organization. February 11, 2021; “The Bio-enhanced Soldier In International Law: Classification And Obligations"; https://finabel.org/the-bio-enhanced-soldier-in-international-law-classification-and-obligations/; //CYang

The first obligation is that the weapon under review would discriminate accurately enough to only target combatants or to be used against legitimate military targets. The second obligation is proportionality, meaning that the use of a weapon must be proportional to the military objective and must keep civilian casualties to a minimum. The final obligation is to avoid unnecessary suffering. This, however, can be rather problematic when it comes to countermeasures against enhanced soldiers as the standards neutralising personnel are different from those governing material. If the reinforced soldier in question falls under the category of “material”, then the level of severity for neutralising the system will be higher. It is therefore essential that a legal categorisation of reinforced soldiers is created from the outset. This could be problematic since states could have divergent understandings of how this category of soldiers should be classified, thus leading to countermeasures that would not comply with the laws of warfare regarding the minimising of suffering.

Human enhancement for military applications would, in certain circumstances, be caught under the obligations of compliance with IHL. This is because it could be seen either as means of warfare, or method of warfare, depending on the interpretation. States would have to review whether or not it is compatible with their obligations under the rules of warfare. Such obligations would demand discrimination between civilians and military targets, not to mention the principles of proportionality and unnecessary suffering. However, such would have to be considered on a case-by-case basis, as different technologies could encompass different legal classifications based on their purposes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.