France says no – parallel science clouds any biotech decisions
Kuntz 14 (Marcel, is a Director of Research at CNRS but is not the spokesman of the institution for which he works. “The GMO case in France: Politics, lawlessness and postmodernism”, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5033180/)//LR
On April 13, 2005, MPs Jean-Yves Le Déaut and Christian Ménard16 issued a report for the “Information Mission of the National Assembly on GMOs. “Their conclusions aimed to be “nuanced and if possible, reassuring.” The report reveals clearly the political divide over this topic: Socialists, Communists, and of course the Greens, being opposed to GMOs, whereas the Center and the Right parties being rather in favor (at least supportive of research), with dissenting voices on each side. In an attempt to placate opponents, the report recommended not to allow any new field trial in 2005. It also recommended unpractical burdens on field trials, such as proposition n° 24 “to perform, during the Bt crops field trials, a study of insect populations including bees (number, behavior, reproduction)” or new obstacles prior to marketing, such as performing socio-economic impact studies (as already recommended in the 2000 Aubert report, illustrating the spread of “Green” views). The report is also embedded in typical postmodernist views (see discussion below) such as “to involve the public and local community representatives and associations” (propositions 53 and 55). The French government moved from a precautionary doctrine in 1997 (which occasionally lost sight of science for political reasons) to the development of its own parallel “science” from 2008 onwards (again for political reasons). While successive governments maintained some rhetorical support for “research on GMOs” for years, the last GMO field trial in France (poplar trees as part of an INRA experiment) was terminated on July 13, 2013 (because Minister Le Foll declined to give an answer to an application by INRA to prolong the experimentation). Such a drift from a precautionary approach in 1997 to a de facto ban illustrates the impact of the precautionary principle. The official “public debates” organized in France also moved from the objective of providing information to the decision makers (with a direct link between the latter and experts), and to the public, to a negotiation-type of debate between “stakeholders” and the government, with a limited role for experts (as was the case for the 2007 “debate” on environment). Public debates also became relativist in nature (scientific knowledge is considered as an opinion just like any other opinion, a characteristic of the postmodern ideology).20 Obviously, these debates have not appeased confrontations concerning GMOs. On the contrary, they have encouraged opponents to become more radical asking for more concessions, until the total eradication of GMOs. For example, on May 23, 2011, a group of activists invaded the agronomical research institute (INRA) center in Angers for a “citizen inspection” of a confined experiment using GM pears. This clear act of intimidation was on the pretext that no dialog had been implemented. GMO experimentation sites have gradually become a lawless area for activists. The reason is clear: the strength of the anti-GMO lobbies is directly correlated to the weakness of politicians. With no more GMO fields to destroy in France, they have since started targeting mutagenized varieties employing the same tactics as used against GMOs (they call mutagenized varieties “hidden GMOs”).29 The fact that the term “genetically modified” is semantically vague can be used by opponents to target all new breeding techniques since their final goal is to destroy seed trade which is perceived as “smothering peasants” (see Fig. 1A). Thus, activists have also occasionally invaded Monsanto's facilities (although the company no longer actually sells GM seeds in France) or agricultural organizations’ premises for diverse reasons but usually linked to seed business or seed regulation. In conclusion, GMO cultivation in France is totally blocked (including field trials and GM research) for political reasons, with no foreseeable way to reverse this situation.