Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Transatlantic cyber consensus fails – fundamental differences in data protection, incident reporting, certification

Selga, et al 21 - Non-Resident Fellow with the Digital Innovation Initiative and Transatlantic Leadership program at the Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA). Ēriks is a former Digital Innovation Baltic Fellow at CEPA and is a Visiting Researcher at the Latvian Institute of Foreign Affairs, Associate Scholar at the Foreign Policy Research Institute, and a current Ph.D. Candidate at the University of Hong Kong Faculty of Law, where he is studying the intersection of law and innovation in the context of FinTech and other datafication trends. Ēriks holds a Master’s degree in International Law from Temple Beasley School of Law. Ēriks research will focus on data governance in the transatlantic space and will explore how NATO has adapted to transatlantic digitization. Abigail LaBreck is a rising Senior at Harvard University pursuing a concentration in Government on the Public Policy track, a secondary field in European History, Politics, and Societies. (“Data Divergences Torpedo Transatlantic Cybersecurity Plans,” Center for European Policy Analysis, 10/12/2021, https://cepa.org/data-divergences-torpedo-transatlantic-cybersecurity-plans/ ) PJW

Beyond these basic similarities in encouraging cybersecurity, the two sides disagree on key points. Although the U.S. and Europe vow to cooperate on cybersecurity, the two sides’ divergent approach to data protection threatens to undermine these ambitions. Europe, which often struggles to set common continent-wide rules, employs a centralized privacy regulation. In contrast, the U.S. takes a fragmented approach. Europe takes a tough line, treating all personal data with the sweeping General Data Protection Regulation. The U.S. prefers to judge harm case by case. A fundamental philosophical gulf explains these differences. Europe focuses on protecting personal data, ensuring that individuals retain control. Data privacy and protection are pillars of the European Union charter and the EU is adopting a comprehensive Data Strategy. The U.S. prefers a laissez-faire approach. Data privacy legislation remains limited to the state level (witness California’s privacy law) or industry by industry. The U.S. Federal Data Strategy sets a foundation for collecting and using data in federal agencies, without cross-agency data centralization. Both Europe and the U.S. do at least agree on the urgency of the cybersecurity challenge. Recent hacks of critical infrastructure at SolarWinds, Colonial Pipeline, and NotPetya highlight a common transatlantic vulnerability. Ubiquitous IoT devices and smart infrastructure create a growing danger of cyberattacks. In response, Europe and the U.S have established cybersecurity agencies. The EU has set up the Agency for Network and Information Security (ENISA). The U.S. has the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency (CISA). These agencies urge both governments and businesses to deploy what Europe calls “state of the art” security and the U.S. designates “industry best practices.” Beyond these basic similarities in encouraging cybersecurity, the two sides disagree on key points. Europe’s NIS Directive mandates the private sector to take concrete actions. The U.S.’s NIST Framework limits itself to urging voluntary action. Certification represents another dividing line. The EU wants ENISA to “certify” cybersecurity preparedness. The U.S. has not acted on certification and some U.S. tech companies say certification monitoring could be dangerous, opening up systems to attacks. Perhaps the most crucial divergence concerns incident reporting. When a company discovers a hack, when should they be required to report it to regulators and customers? If it goes public before facts are clear, it risks spreading incomplete or even false information – and sparking an unneeded panic. Report too late, though, and the untreated danger could spread. The two sides’ divergent privacy policies result in a dangerous split to deal with this dilemma. Europe imposes a high, centralized standard to report data breaches, with a single set of rules for all companies. If an individuals’ data is divulged, the individual must be informed – full stop. The U.S., as with privacy protections, is less stringent. Under many state laws, companies are not required to notify consumers until, after a “reasonable” investigation, it is determined that customers have suffered actual harm.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.