Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cybersecurity norms fail – the state centric foundation of international law has made it obsolete

Katagiri, 21 (Nori Katagiri, M.A., Columbia University, M.A., University of Pennsylvania, Ph.D., University of Pennsylvania, professor of political science, 18-2-2021, " Why international law and norms do little in preventing non-state cyber attacks" Journal of Cybersecurity, https://doi.org/10.1093/cybsec/tyab009, LASA-CSK)

This article exposes at least two ironies, one regarding international law and the other about cyberspace norms. The first irony is that international law has promoted state centrism for so many years that, once in the cyber age, the very legal foundation that is supposed to protect states has become the major obstacle to promoting state security. The other irony is about norm politics; major powers in cybersecurity – especially the USA, Russia, and China, each of which have promoted norms – have been among the greatest violators. This article suggests that all kinds of moral charges can be made about embedded hypocrisy and the double standard of words and deeds. Worse, these powerful states are not just violating each other’s norms but creating a strategic environment that permits norm contestation and overlooks further violations, including those committed by nonstate actors. The hypocrisies, however, precisely underscore the true state of cybersecurity where power and interest forge around powerful states, and there is limited space for international law and norms to play a larger role in regulating their behavior. This article indicates the need for the reconsideration of state commitment to the existing international legal and norm system as a preventive mechanism against nonstate OCO. Space limitation precludes further discussions of specific policies on international law and norms beyond the ones that I presented above. This analysis, however, provides a sufficient narrative that reform is necessary for the international system to be effective against nonstate OCO. It is apparent that cyberspace norms – especially principles like those of distinction, due diligence, and proportionality – must be updated to reflect the growing influence of nonstate actors in cyberspace. At the same time, it remains true that states have sought to reform the system and make norms robust over the years without achieving meaningful change. Rather than promoting international law and norms as a means of preventing cyberattacks, states and private actors are likely to depend more on themselves to prevent nonstate attacks. For one, scholars have called for a variety of active defense countermeasures to be adopted. A reasonable action we can expect states to take is the consideration of how international law and norms can aid state conduct of active defense in cyberspace. In this context, what is required is a series of examinations regarding what specific aspects of international law ought to be reformed and which one of the many ideas and principles can be facilitated to generate more effects than before.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.