Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US will always compromise – economic incentives, big tech pressure, & Biden foreign policy

Xirui Li 22 - pursuing doctoral studies at the S Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS) of Nanyang Technological University (NTU) in Singapore. She is also a non-resident research fellow at the Intellisia Institute in Guangzhou, China. (“BEHIND THE US CONCESSIONS TO THE EU ON TRANSATLANTIC DATA TRANSFERS,” AsiaGlobal Online, 04/13/2022, https://www.asiaglobalonline.hku.hk/behind-us-concessions-eu-transatlantic-data-transfers ) PJW

While the US and European Union announced agreement in principle on a new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework, the fundamental differences between the approaches of the two sides to data governance remain, writes Li Xirui of the S Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore.

During US President Joe Biden’s March visit to Europe, the European Commission and the United States announced that they had agreed in principle on a new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework (TADPF). It is a breakthrough between the two parties on data transfers after the Privacy Shield was invalidated by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in 2020 due to concerns about the shortcomings in US laws that impede the protection of personal data and are in conflict with Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

Such an agreement could not have been reached without what the Biden administration called “unprecedented commitments” made by the US. The legal text of the framework has yet to be published, but the US has promised to address the CJEU’s concerns on data privacy and security. Some of the measures are specified in the statement released by the White House. For instance, it will put new safeguards to ensure that surveillance activities are necessary and proportionate in pursuit of defined national security objectives. It will establish a multi-layer independent redress mechanism with binding authority that can apply remedial measures, and it will enhance rigorous and layered oversight of signals intelligence activities.

After a yearlong battle over data traffic between the two parties, why did the United States make such compromises? No doubt economic interests mattered, but the ongoing Ukraine-Russia war made the deal more imperative. Although the announcement of the TADPF provides temporary relief for businesses which faced uncertainty over their ability to move data between the US and Europe, the future of the EU-US cooperation on digital data traffic is not promising due to the divergence between the two sides in their data governance approaches and underlying norms.

Given the ever more digitalized world economy, the significance of data flows is profound. Trade and investment between the US and Europe, valued at US$7.1 trillion, are underpinned by digital data flows between the two. In 2020, Europe was the US’s main commercial partner in the digital economy. The US registered a surplus of US$105 billion in the trade of digitally-enabled services with Europe; it exported US$247 billion and imported US$142 billion.

About 46 percent of US digitally enabled services were exported to Europe, while about 45 percent of those services was imported from across Atlantic Ocean. The trade in digitally enabled services between the US and Europe was much more than US digital trade with the rest of the world. Meanwhile, the US only accounted for about 14 percent of total exports and 25 percent of total imports of the digitally enabled services of the 27 EU members. This data indicate that the US depends more on the EU in terms of the development of the digital economy rather the other way around.

The US government is recognizing the need to cooperate with big technology firms, even as these companies are putting more and more pressure on Washington on digital trade policy. The Biden administration has been partnering with tech giants on cybersecurity. Meanwhile, due to the close links between them, including donations to the president’s election campaign, appointments of tech-sector executives to senior government positions, and the extensive lobbying activities by the companies, the White House simply cannot ignore the demands of the tech giants such as Meta Platforms, Alphabet and Microsoft. While they are headquartered in the US, Europe is a large market for them. The lack of an agreement on data transfers between the EU and the US created uncertainties and risks including the possibility of suspension of their operations in Europe.

Meta Platforms, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, had openly stated that it may be forced to retreat from Europe if authorities on both sides of the Atlantic cannot reach a new framework on data flow to replace Privacy Shield. Europe is the group’s second largest market after the US and Canada. Going by 2020 data, withdrawal from the European market would mean the loss of 24 percent of the company’s total revenue and 25 percent of its turnover. Meta Platform and other US tech giants simply cannot afford to lose lucrative European market. The major tech firms are not able to address the EU’s concerns over data privacy by themselves without the US federal government making improvements to data law and regulations. This means that the tech companies will have to step up their engagement with Washington.

Without doubt, economic interests are the main motivation for the Biden administration to reach a deal on transatlantic data transfers. But they are not sufficient enough a reason to explain why a compromise has now been reached after over a year of negotiations. There is certainly a geopolitical imperative that prompted Washington to agree to compromise: Russia’s war on Ukraine.

When Biden came into office in January 2021, he vowed to European allies that “America is back”, that “the transatlantic alliance is back”. Under his leadership, the US has significantly increased its engagement with Europe and reaffirmed its commitment to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). Speeding up transatlantic cooperation on technology is a very important part of Washington’s re-engagement efforts.

On his first visit to Europe last year, Biden agreed to set up the US-EU Trade and Technology Council (TTC). It followed that on this recent trip, he would reach a preliminary deal on data transfers. The US is looking to forge a transatlantic tech alliance. This would be a logical step in shoring up the security alliance that was so damaged under the previous administration of Donald Trump, who had openly expressed doubts about the utility of NATO and was critical of fellow members for puling their fair share of the costs of the defense of Europe. Reversing Trump’s approach was a priority on Biden’s foreign-policy agenda, made all the more critical since Russia invaded Ukraine on February 24, with President Vladimir Putin contending that his actions were compelled by NATO’s expansion to his country’s borders.

Maintaining unity between the US and EU has become an extremely important and urgent goal for the US since the outbreak of the war in Ukraine. The White House acknowledged that Biden’s visit to Europe in March was to consolidate the cohesion of the West in countering Moscow. While in Europe, in addition to the data transfers concessions, the US also made key offers of support to Europe on energy security.

The EU and US agree that financial and economic sanctions are important to stop Russia’s war in Ukraine. But due to its heavy reliance on Russian gas and oil, the EU has hesitated to impose sanctions on Russia’s energy exports. In the joint statement aimed at addressing European energy supply concerns, the US promised to boost shipment of liquified natural gas (LNG) to Europe immediately and over the longer term. This demonstrated Washington’s willingness to contribute to EU energy security at this critical time. By issuing the joint statement on TADPF, the US also expressed its understanding of and willingness to assuage European worries on data transfers and security. These two statements clearly underscored the Biden administration’s determination to strengthen mutual trust between the US and EU, bolster the transatlantic alliance, and solidify their joint efforts against Russia over Ukraine.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.