Burden-sharing disputes will not destroy NATO – their strengths outweigh weaknesses
Koivula and Ossa ‘22 - Tommi Koivula (Ph.D.) works as professor of strategic and defense studies at the Finnish National Defence University; Heljä Ossa is a researcher and doctoral student at the Department of Warfare in the Finnish National Defence University (Palgrave Macmillan, “NATO’s Burden-Sharing Disputes”, https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/978-3-030-93539-9.pdf )//RG
NATO’s ability to incorporate a large number of member countries and to broaden the agenda according to the current security context are some of the Alliance’s most significant advantages and strengths. On the other side of the coin there is, however, the risk of over-expansion of membership and tasks. The growing and diversifying membership along with the ever-growing task list are closely linked to the burden-sharing debate as the Alliance needs to allocate scarce resources to accommodate the needs of more allies and to manage tasks that range from territo- rial defence to human emergencies, such as the Covid-19 pandemic. The ultimate issue is thus not that the allies’ contributions are imbalanced but that the amount of demands for NATO is growing. It is possible, even likely, that the burden-sharing debate will intensify in the future. It is, however, important not to look at the burden-sharing debate from too narrow a perspective, which might lead us into the conclusion that the debate endangers the existence of the whole Alliance. As we have pointed out, burden-sharing should not be considered as a separate discussion but as an economic, political and social phenomenon that is formed of a complex set of interlinked factors. Considering this and the reasons behind organisational termination and survival, it is premature to claim that burden-sharing disputes alone could lead to NATO’s crumbling. The debate is closely linked to other problems, such as trust issues among allies and diverse threat perceptions, which can severely damage NATO’s ability to survive future crisis. On the other hand, NATO’s strengths discussed above balance these weaknesses and speak against the possibility of termination of NATO even when facing severe crisis.